Remove link between eAuction and Framework agreement

OP-TED / ePO

The eProcurement Ontology provides the formal, semantic foundation for the creation and reuse of linked open data in the domain of public procurement in the EU.

European Union Public License 1.2

58 stars 18 forks source link

Remove link between eAuction and Framework agreement #188

Closed eprocurementontology closed 2 years ago

eprocurementontology commented 5 years ago

During a discussion on the differences between "Framework agreement", "eAuction" and "Dynamic Purchase System", we decided that "eAuction" does not require a link to "Framework agreement" as they are indirectly linked via "Procedure" and "Contract". Please remove the link.

WG decision 09/01/2018

muricna commented 5 years ago

The summary of the meeting of 5 March seems to overturn this decision. It is to be verified as to whether the link between DPS and eAuction with FA is possible without the predicates.

jseguraf commented 5 years ago

The "Framework Agreement" is linked to eAuction through the predicate "uses eAuction". Moreover, the "DPS" is also linked to eAuction through the "uses eAuction" predicate.

JachymHercher commented 5 years ago

This seems a bit strange. 1) A procedure/lot which does not involve DPS nor framework agreement could also use an eAuction. Is there a "uses eAuction" predicate in such cases? 2) If any type of procedure/lot can "use eAuction", isn't it simpler modelling to just have one predicate between procedure/lot and eAuction rather than many separate ones?

JachymHercher commented 5 years ago

May I ask you to reopen this issue please?

jseguraf commented 5 years ago

The issue is open again.

muricna commented 3 years ago

Since DPS, Framework Agreement Technique and eAuction are all techniques more than one technique can be used in a lot or a procedure therefore no direct link is required between the techniques themselves. The link FrameworkTechnique uses eAuction should be removed.

andreea-pasare commented 2 years ago

Below is a diagram depicting how Technique Usage concepts are modeled in ePO 3.0.1: