OP-TED / ePO

The eProcurement Ontology provides the formal, semantic foundation for the creation and reuse of linked open data in the domain of public procurement in the EU.
European Union Public License 1.2
58 stars 18 forks source link

Comparison of items #356

Closed idolum closed 2 years ago

idolum commented 2 years ago

Often the offered packages of items of the same type are different, so that the prices of the packages cannot be used to compare them. This is often resolved by providing a standardized unit that is priced.

User Story

A person wants to by printer paper. Via the catalogue print paper by two different manufacturers are available, but the packaged and priced them differently:

Actually, the price for one sheet of paper is the same, but it is hard to tell for the buying person.

Thus, for A and B the following information is provided:

Proposal

In CEN/WS BII3 it was modelled like this

image

Definitions

andreea-pasare commented 2 years ago

image

giorgialodi commented 2 years ago

What does it mean that a price has a delivery location? A price? Are you sure? Probably the item but I don't think a price. A price may include the delivery part but it is very strange saying that a price has a delivery location.

idolum commented 2 years ago

@giorgialodi It's not the delivery location of the price, but the price might depend on the delivery location of the price. For example, the magazine in front of me: Its a German magazine and costs in Germany 4.90 EUR. If you order it from Austria or The Netherlands it costs 5.50 EUR, from Luxembourg 5.80 EUR, from Switzerland 9.50 CHF and from Hungary 2150 HUF.

idolum commented 2 years ago

image

@andreea-pasare So the "Standardized unit quantity" is covered by the epo-ecat:hasBaseQuantity of the related hasStandardizedUnitPrice instance, is it?

andreea-pasare commented 2 years ago

@idolum Yes, this is the case. Here's an example of instantiating the model: image

giorgialodi commented 2 years ago

@idolum ok but then the model above is strange. That model says that the price has a delivery location but it seems to me that you want to say that there is a portion of the price specification of an item that depends on the delivery location.