OPENER-next / OpenStop

App for collecting OpenStreetMap-compliant accessibility data in public transport
https://openstop.app
GNU General Public License v3.0
63 stars 13 forks source link

Adding bus routes to stops #229

Open codeinabox opened 6 months ago

codeinabox commented 6 months ago

Idea

Firstly, thank you for this great app! I've been using it regularly and been impressed with the level of detail it captures. One feature I'd love, though I appreciate it could be quite tricky, is the ability to add bus stops to routes or at the very least ability to create notes about what bus routes stop there.

Bug Relation

No response

Implementation

No response

Additional Info

No response

Robbendebiene commented 5 months ago

Thanks for the suggestion. We are pleased that you are using the app. 🙂

the ability to add bus stops to routes

As you already mentioned this is kinda tricky to do with questions because the negation "this bus stop does not belong to this bus route" cannot explicitly be modelled. This means questions for bus stops not belonging to a certain route would be asked indefinitely.

However one could imagine that we ask this question for bus stops that is not assigned to any bus route. This is certainly not perfect as the current data could be incomplete.

A while ago we wanted to have something similar for stop_area relations, so that users can add/group elements of a stop. Ideally we would have a separate "relation editor" for that, though we haven't put much thought into the design and integration yet. So further ideas or concepts are greatly appreciated 🙂

ability to create notes about what bus routes stop there.

Creating and participating in notes is something we definitely want to add as there will always be special scenarios the app cannot handle. Please post any ideas, requests or use cases here: #154