search

OPUASF / UASF

BIP148 & UASF FAQ
http://uasf.org
7 stars 48 forks source link

Miner enforcement of BIP148 #4

Closed chrisacheson closed 7 years ago

chrisacheson commented 7 years ago

This section is incorrect:

What do miners need to do to enforce BIP148?

Miners should update their mining software to produce blocks with version bit 1 enabled prior to August 1st, 2017. Miners do not need to create SegWit blocks or make any other changes. After activation of SegWit, at a minimum, miners should also make sure they have a border node that filters out invalid blocks.

Miners need to be running a BIP148 node. Signalling segwit support is not enough. If a miner is signalling for segwit but not enforcing BIP148, on August 1st they'll follow the wrong side of the chain split.

alp-bitcoin commented 7 years ago

This is covered in the Border Node case. Border Nodes will prevent them from following the wrong chain.

chrisacheson commented 7 years ago

Wording is unclear. An alternative:

Prior to August 1st, 2017, miners should either:

  1. Update their node software to a BIP148-enforcing version; or
  2. Run a BIP148 border node to filter out invalid blocks, and update their existing mining software to produce blocks with version 1 bit enabled, to vote for Segwit activation