OSGeo / PROJ-data

Repository for proj datum grids (for use by PROJ 7 or later)
Other
72 stars 33 forks source link

Seeking license for grids for vertical transformations to EVRF2019 #52

Open rouault opened 3 years ago

rouault commented 3 years ago

Email just sent to crs-eu@bkg.bund.de """ Hello,

The latest release of the EPSG v10.008 dataset includes a number of transformations between many vertical CRS and EVRF2019, that involve using grids. The EPSG dataset points to your website as the source for those transformations. I could find the related grids navigating from the links starting at http://crs.bkg.bund.de/crseu/crs/eu-national.php , but I could not find any mention of the licensing for those .asc files. I'd appreciate if you could indicate it to me.

Background: I'm one of the developers of the PROJ open source software (https://proj.org) widely used to perform coordinate transformations, and along with the software, we provide the needed grid datasets at https://cdn.proj.org/ so that users can seemlessly perform coordinate transformations. One of the condition for inclusion in this collection of grids is that the grids are released under an Open Source Initiative approved license (such as Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0, Public Domain, etc.) """

rouault commented 3 years ago

Last answer from BKG on May 11th 2021: """ Dear Even,

Please excuse my delayed reply. Unfortunately there is still no progress in that matter. One reason is, that I need the agreement of our administration. Currently we have a principled discussion about licensing on BKG, and nobody wants to make a decision before the end of this discussion. The other problem is, that I got the data from the European countries. I asked them for the agreement to publish these transformations on the website. No I am not sure, whether I have to ask them again for licensing.

Kind regards """