OSTP / PhysicsArtofModelling

First year calculus-based textbook
19 stars 10 forks source link

Footnote 1 in Section 24.1 is mistaken #342

Open MichaelAllenWarner opened 2 years ago

MichaelAllenWarner commented 2 years ago

Footnote 1 of Section 24.1 asserts that under a Lorentz boost, the component of force that's perpendicular to the boost-direction is left unchanged. That's not true, as the force three-vector $\vec f$ is not the spatial component of a four-vector (rather, the quantity $\gamma \vec f$ is the spatial component of the four-force).

Under a boost along the $x$-axis, the $y$-component of force actually transforms like:

$$ f_y^\prime = \frac{fy}{\gamma{boost} \left( 1 \pm \beta_{boost} \beta_x \right)} $$

where

Only in the Newtonian limit ($\gamma{boost} \approx 1$, and $\beta{boost} \beta_x \approx 0$) does $f_y^\prime \approx f_y$.

ryanmartinneutrino commented 2 years ago

Oh, thanks for pointing that one out! Yes indeed, we will fix that next time we commit some updates.