soc-pe-bot
commented
1 year ago Team's Response
Thanks for raising your issues!
As mentioned in our DG that, our target customers are uni students, so I believe 10000 might be way more than enough for these kind of customers. And we set a constraint for user of our application, so that the items that cost more than 10000 are not eligible to use in our app. Because when the price is too high, the app requires higher security, which is not in our scope and not suitable for a CLI program
Items for the Tester to Verify
:question: Issue response
Team chose [response.Rejected]
- [x] I disagree
Reason for disagreement: To begin, this bug is reported during PE Phase 1 - Part I where testers focus lies on UG and manual testing section of DG as mentioned in module website as shown below.
Hence, target user profile in DG was ignored. Instead "target users" are interpreted as "rental business managers who keep track of all of their customers" as stated in the introduction of UG as shown in picture below.
In addition, there was no mentioning of "our target customers are uni students" in the UG. Hence, it should be logical to assume that the scope of the product includes the usage for practical business transaction context (target user assumed to be rental business manager).
Also, the statement "we set a constraint for user of our application, so that the items that cost more than 10000 are not eligible to use in our app. Because when the price is too high, the app requires higher security" claimed by the dev team was not explicitly written in the DG product scope either as well as shown below.
With this in mind, there are few reasons why rental price capped at $10000 should be treated as a feature flaw (Low severity):
(1) Practical business transaction can go above $10000 (e.g. cumulative rental price for renting expensive props for a luxurious wedding).
(2) It is better to allow a greater allowance will ensure smoother operations since unique cases in (1) are already factored.
As shown in picture, the app is for rental business managers and the price limit of $10000 can be too low at times. For instance, if some users want to rent expensive props for a luxurious wedding, they would probably opt for something more expensive.