OWASP / ASVS

Application Security Verification Standard
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
2.74k stars 669 forks source link

V6 - "Stored cryptography" vs "cryptography" #2375

Open randomstuff opened 1 day ago

randomstuff commented 1 day ago

The V6 chapter is now called "Stored Cryptography" (and was before named "Cryptography"). I actually missed that point until now.

Do we want V6 to be only about Stored Cryptography only?

Some things here would me applicable in other context (such as "Random Values").

If we want V6 to be about "Stored Cryptography", this should probably be clearer in the introduction. In this case, #2310 for example should go somewhere else.

If we keep V6 "Stored Encryption" and V9 "Communication Encryption":

Related #2252, #2310

elarlang commented 18 hours ago

This is defining the scope for V6. We need to define, what and based on what rules fits to this paragraph.

In:

Questionable:

For example, 6.4.1 in the secret management section - the main problem to solve is incorrect handling of secrets, although the solution to solve is to use cryptography (key vault). 6.4.1 got merge from 2.10.4, probably it was not good move.

danielcuthbert commented 12 hours ago

If im honest, V6 Cryptography is where I'm leaning towards