search

Occupation-Ontology / OccO

OccO: Occupation Ontology
4 stars 13 forks source link

Non-matching definitions between .owl file and FOIS 2023 paper. #12

Open giacomodecolle opened 10 months ago

giacomodecolle commented 10 months ago

Hello,

the current definitions of most important terms in OccO are not corresponding to the definitions provided in the FOIS 2023 paper. By "most important terms", I refer to occupation holder, occupation disposition, occupation role, occupation activity, skill, ability.

Expected behavior would be to align the current definitions in the owl file to the definitions provided in the FOIS 2023 paper.

zhengj2007 commented 10 months ago

@giacomodecolle Could you please add the definitions of the terms that you find not correctly represented in the ontology in the issue? So, we can update them in the OccO ontology. Thanks!

giacomodecolle commented 9 months ago

New definitions taken from FOIS 2023 paper:

occupation holder: A human bearing an occupation role or occupation disposition. occupation role: A role borne by a human that, if realized, is realized when the bearer provides labor or services in exchange for compensation as specified by some deontic declaration. occupation disposition: A disposition that, if realized, is realized when the bearer intends to, and does, exercise abilities and skills in pursuit of obtaining or maintaining an occupation role. ability: A disposition that inheres in a human, exists in virtue of natural biological development, and is such that if realized, is realized in the performance of one or more tasks. skill: A disposition that inheres in a human, exists in virtue of training, and is such that if realized, is realized in the performance of one or more tasks with reliable high proficiency. occupation activity: A process in which an occupation holder participates that realizes either an occupation disposition or occupation role.

zhengj2007 commented 9 months ago

occupation role: A role borne by a human that, if realized, is realized when the bearer provides labor or services in exchange for compensation as specified by some deontic declaration.

Is it same as OMRSE: job role? A role in human social processes that, if realized, is realized when the bearer provides labor or services in exchange for a wage or salary as specified by some deontic declaration.

If so, OccO needs to import OMRSE job role.

giacomodecolle commented 9 months ago

Yes, I think that as it stands the terms might be equivalent. I think that OMRSE is currently working on an update so we might have to wait until their update is ready to import the term. Given that we do have an OccO occupation role, we could update the definition in the meantime in order to reflect the paper and then eventually substitute it with the OMRSE term when the time comes. When you make a decision about these changes, would you please let me know so that I can update my fork of OccO and then open a pull request with the work I have done on skills definitions?

zhengj2007 commented 9 months ago

I'd like to discuss the issue on the OccO meeting before make any changes.