293 unlock new designs for shopify gate

sebpalluel commented 7 months ago

Type

enhancement, documentation

Description

Refactored Shopify feature pages to use new components (OffKeyAuth, OffKeyGate, OffKeyHeader, etc.) for better structure and functionality.
Implemented OffKeyLayout for consistent layout management across Shopify feature pages.
Added OffKeyProfile component for managing user profiles in connected state.
Introduced OffKeyGate component for managing gate states (unlocked, unlocking, used, locked).
Added localization support for new components and states.

Changes walkthrough

Relevant files

Enhancement

12 files

page.tsx `Refactor Auth Page to Use OffKeyAuth Component` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/(notConnected)/@auth/page.tsx Refactored to use `OffKeyAuth` component with localization support. Added `NextIntlClientProvider` for localized messages.	+20/-3
page.tsx `Implement OffKeyHeader in Header Page` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/(notConnected)/@header/page.tsx - Implemented `OffKeyHeader` component for the header section.	+12/-0
layout.tsx `Use OffKeyLayout for Layout Management` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/(notConnected)/layout.tsx Replaced `ShopifyCard` with `OffKeyLayout` for layout management. Added support for rendering header component.	+17/-11
page.tsx `Integrate OffKeyGateSignIn Component` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/(notConnected)/page.tsx - Introduced `OffKeyGateSignIn` component for sign-in functionality.	+6/-11
page.tsx `Implement Connected User Header with OffKeyProfile` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/[address]/@header/page.tsx Utilized `OffKeyHeaderConnected` and `OffKeyProfile` for connected user header.	+32/-0
layout.tsx `Use OffKeyLayout in Address-Specific Layout` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/[address]/layout.tsx Switched to `OffKeyLayout` for layout management in address-specific pages.	+6/-18
page.tsx `Implement OffKeyGate Component for Gate State Management` apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/[address]/page.tsx - Implemented `OffKeyGate` component to manage gate state.	+30/-2
index.ts `Export New Components for Shopify Feature` libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/index.ts Exported new components (`OffKeyAuth`, `OffKeyGate`, `OffKeyGateSignIn`, etc.) from the library.	+8/-0
OffKeyAuth.tsx `Add OffKeyAuth Component for Wallet Authentication` libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx - Added `OffKeyAuth` component for wallet authentication flow.	+119/-0
OffKeyGate.tsx `Introduce OffKeyGate Component` libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.tsx - Introduced `OffKeyGate` component for gate state management.	+64/-0
OffKeyHeader.tsx `Implement OffKeyHeader Component` libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyHeader/OffKeyHeader.tsx - Implemented `OffKeyHeader` component for the header section.	+32/-0
OffKeyProfile.tsx `Add OffKeyProfile Component for User Profile Management` libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx - Added `OffKeyProfile` component for user profile management.	+191/-0

Documentation

1 files

en.json

Add Translations for New Shopify Feature Components

libs/next/i18n/src/messages/en.json

Added translations for new components (OffKeyAuth, OffKeyGate,
OffKeyProfile, etc.).

+34/-0

✨ PR-Agent usage: Comment /help on the PR to get a list of all available PR-Agent tools and their descriptions

vercel[bot] commented 7 months ago

The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git ↗︎

Name	Status	Preview	Comments	Updated (UTC)
back-office	✅ Ready (Inspect)	Visit Preview	💬 Add feedback	Apr 9, 2024 11:10am
marketplace	✅ Ready (Inspect)	Visit Preview	💬 Add feedback	Apr 9, 2024 11:10am
unlock	✅ Ready (Inspect)	Visit Preview	💬 Add feedback	Apr 9, 2024 11:10am

codiumai-pr-agent-free[bot] commented 7 months ago

PR Description updated to latest commit (https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/commit/8d0a4d254b4b9cdb5f7f8e1c889ac0885acd90b9)

codiumai-pr-agent-free[bot] commented 7 months ago

PR Review

⏱️ Estimated effort to review [1-5]	4, due to the extensive changes across multiple files, including new components, refactoring, and localization support. The PR introduces significant enhancements and new features, requiring a thorough review of code quality, functionality, and integration with existing systems.
🧪 Relevant tests	No
🔍 Possible issues	Possible Bug: The use of `useEffect` hooks in `OffKeyProfile.tsx` without a dependency array might lead to unexpected behavior or infinite loops. Consider adding a dependency array to control the effect's execution.
	Code Duplication: Similar code patterns are observed in `OffKeyAuth.tsx` and `OffKeyProfile.tsx` for handling wallet connections. Consider abstracting common logic into reusable hooks or components to reduce duplication and improve maintainability.
	Localization Consistency: Ensure that all user-facing text is included in the localization files and properly utilized in the components. This includes error messages and dynamic content that might not be currently covered.
	Performance Concern: The extensive use of animations and dynamic content in components like `OffKeyGate.tsx` and `OffKeyHeaderConnected.tsx` might impact performance on lower-end devices. Consider optimizing animations and conditional rendering to improve the user experience across all devices.
🔒 Security concerns	No

✨ Review tool usage guide:

**Overview:** The `review` tool scans the PR code changes, and generates a PR review which includes several types of feedbacks, such as possible PR issues, security threats and relevant test in the PR. More feedbacks can be [added](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/tools/review/#general-configurations) by configuring the tool. The tool can be triggered [automatically](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/usage-guide/automations_and_usage/#github-app-automatic-tools-when-a-new-pr-is-opened) every time a new PR is opened, or can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR. - When commenting, to edit [configurations](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/pr_agent/settings/configuration.toml#L23) related to the review tool (`pr_reviewer` section), use the following template: ``` /review --pr_reviewer.some_config1=... --pr_reviewer.some_config2=... ``` - With a [configuration file](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/usage-guide/configuration_options/), use the following template: ``` [pr_reviewer] some_config1=... some_config2=... ``` See the review [usage page](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/tools/review/) for a comprehensive guide on using this tool.

codiumai-pr-agent-free[bot] commented 7 months ago

PR Code Suggestions

Category	Suggestions
Best practice	Use a more specific error type instead of `any` for error handling in mutations. ___ Consider using a more specific error type in the `onError` callback of your mutations to improve error handling. Using `any` for the error type can make it difficult to handle errors properly since you lose type information. TypeScript provides a way to define custom error types or you can use existing error types that are more specific to the context of the error. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [57-59]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR57-R59) ```diff -onError: (error: any) => { +onError: (error: Error) => { // Handle connection error }, ```
	Avoid using console.log in production code for better code quality. ___ It's a good practice to avoid direct console logging in production code, especially in success or error handlers of mutations. Consider using a more robust logging mechanism or remove the console logs if they were used for debugging purposes. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [54-69]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR54-R69) ```diff -console.log('connected to wallet'); -console.log('error connecting to dapp', error); +// Use a logging library or remove the console.log statements ```
	Use a ternary operator for conditional rendering to improve readability. ___ To improve code readability and maintainability, consider using a ternary operator for conditional rendering based on `walletInStorage.length > 1`. This change would make the component's structure clearer and more concise. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuthSignIn.tsx [34-70]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-a7a38c4ba86bbda1719d0fc1a196c2a6324076a0f3036bf2acb6e8612e42f923R34-R70) ```diff -return walletInStorage && walletInStorage.length > 1 ? ( - - ... - -) : ( -
	Use `className` for consistency with React's conventions. ___ Replace the `class` attribute with `className` to adhere to React's naming conventions. Additionally, remove the `// @ts-expect-error` comment if it's no longer necessary, ensuring TypeScript compatibility. [libs/features/unlock/app-nav/src/lib/OffKeyLogo/OffKeyLogo.tsx [9]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-c320ce308703be0b25aa89d914609ae202e41b9dc8c00c0b2075c59eef9d0ad0R9-R9) ```diff -// @ts-expect-error -class={props.className} +className={props.className} ```
	Remove unused function parameters. ___ Consider removing the unused `container` parameter from the `play` function in your Storybook stories to adhere to best practices and improve code readability. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.stories.tsx [35-36]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-54f8a03cadd7b355809e667b7bfe2e620e4d830e84c59d40c8d9c6bb628c743cR35-R36) ```diff -play: async ({ container }) => { +play: async () => { await screen.findAllByText(/Unlocked/i); }, ```
	Use decorators or parameters for mocking in Storybook. ___ Instead of directly mocking the hooks using `createMock`, consider using a more integrated testing approach with Storybook by utilizing decorators or parameters to provide mock data. This approach can improve maintainability and separation of concerns. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/examples.tsx [36-38]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-073ecf024148eed78fbb8ff30bf2f628c971668ccac1c92296a29dbf19bb38e3R36-R38) ```diff -const mockWallet = createMock(walletApi, 'useWalletAuth'); -mockWallet.mockReturnValue(walletAuthMocks); +// Example using decorators for Storybook +export const decorators = [ + (Story) => ( + + + + ), +]; ```
Maintainability	Extract mutation functions into separate named functions for better maintainability. ___ To improve code maintainability and readability, consider extracting the mutation functions (`mutationFn`, `onSuccess`, `onError`) into separate named functions outside of the component. This not only makes the component cleaner but also makes it easier to test these functions in isolation. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [51-60]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR51-R60) ```diff +const handleConnectWallet = (newWallet: string) => connect(newWallet); +const onConnectWalletSuccess = () => { + console.log('connected to wallet'); + // Handle successful connection +}; +const onConnectWalletError = (error: Error) => { + // Handle connection error +}; const connectWalletMutation = useMutation({ - mutationFn: (newWallet: string) => connect(newWallet), - onSuccess: () => { - console.log('connected to wallet'); - // Handle successful connection - }, - onError: (error: any) => { - // Handle connection error - }, + mutationFn: handleConnectWallet, + onSuccess: onConnectWalletSuccess, + onError: onConnectWalletError, }); ```
	Use ternary operator or separate function for conditional rendering for clarity. ___ For better code readability and maintainability, consider using a ternary operator or a separate rendering function for conditional rendering instead of using the logical AND (`&&`) operator. This can make the code easier to understand, especially for more complex conditional renderings. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx [51-69]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-dd427743a002e3dad8c75f54ed95a9092983490a56a5fc378a0e3ec2a5d6bdf6R51-R69) ```diff -{existingWallet ? ( - -) : ( - -)} +renderAuthComponent() { + if (existingWallet) { + return ; + } else { + return ; + } +} +// Usage: {this.renderAuthComponent()} ```
	Improve variable naming for clarity. ___ Consider using a more descriptive variable name for `t` to improve code readability. For example, `translate` or `tFunction` would make it clearer that this variable is used for internationalization. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyInfo/OffKeyInfo.tsx [40]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-afda0c3e7456144fe461301c4114afbbcca1583d473b3be76f8fc49bf2fd9ecbR40-R40) ```diff -const t = useTranslations('Shopify.OffKeyInfo'); +const translate = useTranslations('Shopify.OffKeyInfo'); ```
	Consolidate state mappings into a single mapping for simplicity. ___ Instead of hardcoding the translations keys and creating separate state mappings for subtitles and main text, consider creating a single mapping that includes all the necessary information for each state. This approach reduces redundancy and simplifies the component's structure. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.tsx [29-39]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-b04caa7332ebff9c207f545552e87b6297915d203992f9e5bfe4f6569ecd2ed8R29-R39) ```diff -const stateToSubtitle = { - [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: t('unlocked-subtitle'), - ... -}; -const stateToMainText = { - [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: t('unlocked-text'), +const stateToContent = { + [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: { subtitle: t('unlocked-subtitle'), mainText: t('unlocked-text') }, ... }; ```
	Define mock functions externally for better modularity. ___ To improve the reusability and readability of your mock functions, consider defining them outside of the `authMocks` function or in a separate utility file. This change can make your tests more modular and easier to maintain. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/examples.tsx [29-31]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-a989bfef297ab964b9c8680402fa4386ede798d35806e0886f124aefe5ca466fR29-R31) ```diff -const mockWallet = createMock(walletApi, 'useWalletAuth'); -mockWallet.mockReturnValue(walletAuthMocks); +// In a separate utility file or outside the function +export const mockWalletAuth = createMock(walletApi, 'useWalletAuth'); +mockWalletAuth.mockReturnValue(walletAuthMocks); ```
	Implement or remove TODO comments to avoid technical debt. ___ Implement the actual logic for `getGateStateForAddress` or remove the `TODO` comment if the function is not meant to be expanded. Leaving `TODO` comments in production code can lead to confusion and technical debt. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/actions/getGateStateForAddress.ts [13-21]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-2ae7ec5f54c9a1e6b79d3b98ed85adfdc3ea0376c7a05dab3885ec0de3c072f5R13-R21) ```diff -// TODO implement -// return __awaiter(this, void 0, void 0, function* () { -// return { -// status: 'locked', -// gateId, -// address, -// }; -// }); -return OffKeyState.Locked; +// Implemented version (example) +return fetchGateState(gateId, address); ```
Enhancement	Improve user feedback by handling the `isConnecting` state in the UI. ___ To enhance the user experience and provide feedback during the connection process, consider handling the `isConnecting` state more explicitly in the UI. For instance, you can disable the connect button and show a loading indicator when `isConnecting` is true. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx [61-68]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-dd427743a002e3dad8c75f54ed95a9092983490a56a5fc378a0e3ec2a5d6bdf6R61-R68) ```diff ```
	Pass state mappings as props for flexibility and maintainability. ___ To ensure that the component is more flexible and easier to maintain, consider passing `stateToBorderColor`, `stateToKeyIcon`, `stateToStatusBackground`, and other similar mappings as props. This change would make the component more reusable and easier to test. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyInfo/OffKeyInfo.tsx [14-31]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-afda0c3e7456144fe461301c4114afbbcca1583d473b3be76f8fc49bf2fd9ecbR14-R31) ```diff -const stateToBorderColor = { - [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: 'border-success-border', - ... -}; +export function OffKeyInfo({ state, offKeyName, className, stateMappings }: OffKeyInfoProps & { stateMappings: StateMappings }) { ```
	Add a description to the `NotConnected` story for better context. ___ Consider adding a description to the `NotConnected` story to provide more context to other developers or designers who might use this story. This can be done by adding a `description` field under `parameters` within the story definition. This helps in understanding the purpose of the story and the specific state it represents without needing to dive into the code. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyHeader/OffKeyHeader.stories.tsx [15-18]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-d8f855fdaaf4a2b04711cd8cf9c209e9c8c5d5696f37a42b5304fafd948c7b5cR15-R18) ```diff export const NotConnected: Story = { args: { title: 'Locked with the Dummy Brand OffKey', }, + parameters: { + docs: { + description: { + story: 'Displays the OffKeyHeader in a not connected state, indicating it is locked with the Dummy Brand OffKey.', + }, + }, + }, }; ```
Possible issue	Ensure props are utilized or remove unnecessary props. ___ The `header` prop is being passed to `OffKeyLayout` but not utilized within it. Ensure that the `header` prop is correctly implemented inside `OffKeyLayout` or reconsider its necessity if it's not being used. [apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/(notConnected)/layout.tsx [24-26]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-300c9bf8ed78b5df256207749beeb349d0c908ad0c736d2ffa6a5f20e3c9090dR24-R26) ```diff - + + {header} {children} {auth} ```

✨ Improve tool usage guide:

**Overview:** The `improve` tool scans the PR code changes, and automatically generates suggestions for improving the PR code. The tool can be triggered [automatically](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/usage-guide/automations_and_usage/#github-app-automatic-tools-when-a-new-pr-is-opened) every time a new PR is opened, or can be invoked manually by commenting on a PR. - When commenting, to edit [configurations](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/pr_agent/settings/configuration.toml#L78) related to the improve tool (`pr_code_suggestions` section), use the following template: ``` /improve --pr_code_suggestions.some_config1=... --pr_code_suggestions.some_config2=... ``` - With a [configuration file](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/usage-guide/configuration_options/), use the following template: ``` [pr_code_suggestions] some_config1=... some_config2=... ``` See the improve [usage page](https://pr-agent-docs.codium.ai/tools/improve/) for a comprehensive guide on using this tool.

Category	Suggestions
Best practice	Use a more specific error type instead of `any` for error handling in mutations. ___ Consider using a more specific error type in the `onError` callback of your mutations to improve error handling. Using `any` for the error type can make it difficult to handle errors properly since you lose type information. TypeScript provides a way to define custom error types or you can use existing error types that are more specific to the context of the error. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [57-59]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR57-R59) ```diff -onError: (error: any) => { +onError: (error: Error) => { // Handle connection error }, ```
	Avoid using console.log in production code for better code quality. ___ It's a good practice to avoid direct console logging in production code, especially in success or error handlers of mutations. Consider using a more robust logging mechanism or remove the console logs if they were used for debugging purposes. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [54-69]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR54-R69) ```diff -console.log('connected to wallet'); -console.log('error connecting to dapp', error); +// Use a logging library or remove the console.log statements ```
	Use a ternary operator for conditional rendering to improve readability. ___ To improve code readability and maintainability, consider using a ternary operator for conditional rendering based on `walletInStorage.length > 1`. This change would make the component's structure clearer and more concise. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuthSignIn.tsx [34-70]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-a7a38c4ba86bbda1719d0fc1a196c2a6324076a0f3036bf2acb6e8612e42f923R34-R70) ```diff -return walletInStorage && walletInStorage.length > 1 ? ( - - ... - -) : ( -
	Use `className` for consistency with React's conventions. ___ Replace the `class` attribute with `className` to adhere to React's naming conventions. Additionally, remove the `// @ts-expect-error` comment if it's no longer necessary, ensuring TypeScript compatibility. [libs/features/unlock/app-nav/src/lib/OffKeyLogo/OffKeyLogo.tsx [9]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-c320ce308703be0b25aa89d914609ae202e41b9dc8c00c0b2075c59eef9d0ad0R9-R9) ```diff -// @ts-expect-error -class={props.className} +className={props.className} ```
	Remove unused function parameters. ___ Consider removing the unused `container` parameter from the `play` function in your Storybook stories to adhere to best practices and improve code readability. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.stories.tsx [35-36]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-54f8a03cadd7b355809e667b7bfe2e620e4d830e84c59d40c8d9c6bb628c743cR35-R36) ```diff -play: async ({ container }) => { +play: async () => { await screen.findAllByText(/Unlocked/i); }, ```
	Use decorators or parameters for mocking in Storybook. ___ Instead of directly mocking the hooks using `createMock`, consider using a more integrated testing approach with Storybook by utilizing decorators or parameters to provide mock data. This approach can improve maintainability and separation of concerns. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/examples.tsx [36-38]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-073ecf024148eed78fbb8ff30bf2f628c971668ccac1c92296a29dbf19bb38e3R36-R38) ```diff -const mockWallet = createMock(walletApi, 'useWalletAuth'); -mockWallet.mockReturnValue(walletAuthMocks); +// Example using decorators for Storybook +export const decorators = [ + (Story) => ( + + + + ), +]; ```
Maintainability	Extract mutation functions into separate named functions for better maintainability. ___ To improve code maintainability and readability, consider extracting the mutation functions (`mutationFn`, `onSuccess`, `onError`) into separate named functions outside of the component. This not only makes the component cleaner but also makes it easier to test these functions in isolation. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [51-60]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR51-R60) ```diff +const handleConnectWallet = (newWallet: string) => connect(newWallet); +const onConnectWalletSuccess = () => { + console.log('connected to wallet'); + // Handle successful connection +}; +const onConnectWalletError = (error: Error) => { + // Handle connection error +}; const connectWalletMutation = useMutation({ - mutationFn: (newWallet: string) => connect(newWallet), - onSuccess: () => { - console.log('connected to wallet'); - // Handle successful connection - }, - onError: (error: any) => { - // Handle connection error - }, + mutationFn: handleConnectWallet, + onSuccess: onConnectWalletSuccess, + onError: onConnectWalletError, }); ```
	Use ternary operator or separate function for conditional rendering for clarity. ___ For better code readability and maintainability, consider using a ternary operator or a separate rendering function for conditional rendering instead of using the logical AND (`&&`) operator. This can make the code easier to understand, especially for more complex conditional renderings. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx [51-69]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-dd427743a002e3dad8c75f54ed95a9092983490a56a5fc378a0e3ec2a5d6bdf6R51-R69) ```diff -{existingWallet ? ( - -) : ( - -)} +renderAuthComponent() { + if (existingWallet) { + return ; + } else { + return ; + } +} +// Usage: {this.renderAuthComponent()} ```
	Improve variable naming for clarity. ___ Consider using a more descriptive variable name for `t` to improve code readability. For example, `translate` or `tFunction` would make it clearer that this variable is used for internationalization. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyInfo/OffKeyInfo.tsx [40]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-afda0c3e7456144fe461301c4114afbbcca1583d473b3be76f8fc49bf2fd9ecbR40-R40) ```diff -const t = useTranslations('Shopify.OffKeyInfo'); +const translate = useTranslations('Shopify.OffKeyInfo'); ```
	Consolidate state mappings into a single mapping for simplicity. ___ Instead of hardcoding the translations keys and creating separate state mappings for subtitles and main text, consider creating a single mapping that includes all the necessary information for each state. This approach reduces redundancy and simplifies the component's structure. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.tsx [29-39]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-b04caa7332ebff9c207f545552e87b6297915d203992f9e5bfe4f6569ecd2ed8R29-R39) ```diff -const stateToSubtitle = { - [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: t('unlocked-subtitle'), - ... -}; -const stateToMainText = { - [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: t('unlocked-text'), +const stateToContent = { + [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: { subtitle: t('unlocked-subtitle'), mainText: t('unlocked-text') }, ... }; ```
	Define mock functions externally for better modularity. ___ To improve the reusability and readability of your mock functions, consider defining them outside of the `authMocks` function or in a separate utility file. This change can make your tests more modular and easier to maintain. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/examples.tsx [29-31]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-a989bfef297ab964b9c8680402fa4386ede798d35806e0886f124aefe5ca466fR29-R31) ```diff -const mockWallet = createMock(walletApi, 'useWalletAuth'); -mockWallet.mockReturnValue(walletAuthMocks); +// In a separate utility file or outside the function +export const mockWalletAuth = createMock(walletApi, 'useWalletAuth'); +mockWalletAuth.mockReturnValue(walletAuthMocks); ```
	Implement or remove TODO comments to avoid technical debt. ___ Implement the actual logic for `getGateStateForAddress` or remove the `TODO` comment if the function is not meant to be expanded. Leaving `TODO` comments in production code can lead to confusion and technical debt. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/actions/getGateStateForAddress.ts [13-21]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-2ae7ec5f54c9a1e6b79d3b98ed85adfdc3ea0376c7a05dab3885ec0de3c072f5R13-R21) ```diff -// TODO implement -// return __awaiter(this, void 0, void 0, function* () { -// return { -// status: 'locked', -// gateId, -// address, -// }; -// }); -return OffKeyState.Locked; +// Implemented version (example) +return fetchGateState(gateId, address); ```
Enhancement	Improve user feedback by handling the `isConnecting` state in the UI. ___ To enhance the user experience and provide feedback during the connection process, consider handling the `isConnecting` state more explicitly in the UI. For instance, you can disable the connect button and show a loading indicator when `isConnecting` is true. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx [61-68]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-dd427743a002e3dad8c75f54ed95a9092983490a56a5fc378a0e3ec2a5d6bdf6R61-R68) ```diff ```
	Pass state mappings as props for flexibility and maintainability. ___ To ensure that the component is more flexible and easier to maintain, consider passing `stateToBorderColor`, `stateToKeyIcon`, `stateToStatusBackground`, and other similar mappings as props. This change would make the component more reusable and easier to test. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyInfo/OffKeyInfo.tsx [14-31]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-afda0c3e7456144fe461301c4114afbbcca1583d473b3be76f8fc49bf2fd9ecbR14-R31) ```diff -const stateToBorderColor = { - [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: 'border-success-border', - ... -}; +export function OffKeyInfo({ state, offKeyName, className, stateMappings }: OffKeyInfoProps & { stateMappings: StateMappings }) { ```
	Add a description to the `NotConnected` story for better context. ___ Consider adding a description to the `NotConnected` story to provide more context to other developers or designers who might use this story. This can be done by adding a `description` field under `parameters` within the story definition. This helps in understanding the purpose of the story and the specific state it represents without needing to dive into the code. [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyHeader/OffKeyHeader.stories.tsx [15-18]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-d8f855fdaaf4a2b04711cd8cf9c209e9c8c5d5696f37a42b5304fafd948c7b5cR15-R18) ```diff export const NotConnected: Story = { args: { title: 'Locked with the Dummy Brand OffKey', }, + parameters: { + docs: { + description: { + story: 'Displays the OffKeyHeader in a not connected state, indicating it is locked with the Dummy Brand OffKey.', + }, + }, + }, }; ```
Possible issue	Ensure props are utilized or remove unnecessary props. ___ The `header` prop is being passed to `OffKeyLayout` but not utilized within it. Ensure that the `header` prop is correctly implemented inside `OffKeyLayout` or reconsider its necessity if it's not being used. [apps/unlock/app/[locale]/shopify/[gateId]/(notConnected)/layout.tsx [24-26]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/294/files#diff-300c9bf8ed78b5df256207749beeb349d0c908ad0c736d2ffa6a5f20e3c9090dR24-R26) ```diff - + + {header} {children} {auth} ```

OfflineHQ / marketplace