Closed sebpalluel closed 7 months ago
vercel[bot]
commented
7 months ago The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git ↗︎
| Name | Status | Preview | Comments | Updated (UTC) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| back-office | ✅ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | 💬 Add feedback | Apr 26, 2024 5:07pm |
| marketplace | ✅ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | 💬 Add feedback | Apr 26, 2024 5:07pm |
| unlock | ✅ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | 💬 Add feedback | Apr 26, 2024 5:07pm |
codiumai-pr-agent-free[bot]
commented
7 months ago PR Description updated to latest commit (https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/commit/f630df84fdb68c9e250181cb13a04a42471580c1)
codiumai-pr-agent-free[bot]
commented
7 months ago | ⏱️ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 5, because the PR introduces a significant amount of changes across multiple files and components, including new hooks, component modifications, and integration with external APIs. The complexity is high due to the need to understand the interactions between different parts of the system, such as authentication, customer status handling, and UI updates based on state changes. |
| 🧪 Relevant tests | Yes |
| 🔍 Possible issues | Possible Bug: The use of `toLowerCase()` directly on potentially undefined properties could lead to runtime errors. It's safer to ensure the property exists before calling `toLowerCase()`. |
| Performance Concern: There are multiple places where the code could be optimized to avoid unnecessary re-renders or computations, especially in context providers and hooks. | |
| 🔒 Security concerns | No apparent security vulnerabilities were introduced in the changes. However, thorough testing and code review should be conducted to ensure that all user input is properly sanitized and that there are no potential data leaks. |
codiumai-pr-agent-free[bot]
commented
7 months ago | Category | Suggestions |
| Enhancement |
Replace
___
**The |
Enhance error handling in the mutation's onError callback.___ **The error handling in theonError callback of connectWalletMutation only checks for a specific error message. It's recommended to handle different types of errors more robustly or log them appropriately for better debugging and user feedback.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx [82-84]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-dd427743a002e3dad8c75f54ed95a9092983490a56a5fc378a0e3ec2a5d6bdf6R82-R84) ```diff if (error.message.includes('Wallet address does not match')) { setAccountNotMatching(true); +} else { + console.error('Unhandled error:', error); } ``` | |
Add default text for missing
___
**To ensure that the component handles the absence of | |
| Best practice |
Use a function to dynamically generate wallet addresses for testing.___ **ThewalletInStorage array includes hardcoded addresses which might not reflect dynamic testing scenarios. Consider using a function or a factory to generate these addresses dynamically based on the test requirements.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.stories.tsx [45]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-d3cf1bf6ba1f6547521d8358ee0dbd3cbf52ec83cebf682e75620a1ded537602R45-R45) ```diff -walletInStorage: [{ address }, { address: '0x214123135' }], +walletInStorage: generateWalletAddresses(), ``` |
Replace direct console logging with a conditional check for environment or a dedicated error handling mechanism.___ **Replace theconsole.log with a more robust error handling mechanism. Logging to the console is not suitable for production environments as it can expose sensitive information and does not provide a way to centrally manage errors. Consider using a dedicated error reporting service or at least wrapping the logging in a development mode check.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [85]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR85-R85) ```diff -console.log('error connecting to dapp', error); +if (process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development') { + console.error('Error connecting to dapp:', error); +} else { + // Send error to monitoring service + monitoringService.reportError(error); +} ``` | |
Use specific error handling in catch blocks to improve error management.___ **Use a more specific error type in the catch block to handle different types of errorsappropriately. Using a generic error catch can make debugging harder and might not provide the necessary information or actions based on the type of error.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [150-152]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR150-R152) ```diff } catch (e) { - console.error('Error signing out', e); + if (e instanceof NetworkError) { + console.error('Network error during sign out:', e); + } else { + console.error('Unexpected error during sign out:', e); + } throw e; } ``` | |
Link TODO comments to an issue tracker for better tracking and clarity.___ **Avoid using inline comments for TODOs without a clear action plan or ticket reference.This can lead to forgotten or unclear intentions in the codebase. Instead, link TODOs to an issue tracker or provide more detailed comments.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [87]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR87-R87) ```diff -//TODO: Handle connection error display +// TODO: Implement user-friendly error display for connection issues. See issue #1234 in the issue tracker for more details. ``` | |
Use TypeScript enums for
___
**To enhance the type safety and readability of the code, consider using TypeScript enums | |
Add optional chaining to handle potential null or undefined responses safely.___ **Consider handling the case wheremintLoyaltyCardWithPassword might throw an exception or return a null/undefined response before accessing the status property.**
[libs/integrations/external-api-handlers/src/lib/shopify/index.spec.ts [222-223]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-df93842e018141cf209891b7f7fa3c10fbc063d5eed17ace2701d2d12a234844R222-R223)
```diff
const response = await shopifyHandler.mintLoyaltyCardWithPassword(options);
-expect(response.status).toBe(401);
+expect(response?.status).toBe(401);
```
| |
Use descriptive naming for mock data to enhance the readability and maintainability of tests.___ **To improve test clarity and maintainability, use descriptive names for mock values andconstants, particularly for addresses and other identifiers.** [libs/integrations/external-api-handlers/src/lib/shopify/index.spec.ts [561-565]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-df93842e018141cf209891b7f7fa3c10fbc063d5eed17ace2701d2d12a234844R561-R565) ```diff -address: 'test-address', -shop: 'example.myshopify.com', +address: 'mockTestAddress', +shop: 'mockExampleShop.myshopify.com', timestamp: Date.now().toString(), -signature: 'validSignature', +signature: 'mockValidSignature', ``` | |
| Maintainability |
Ensure relevant parameters are passed to the
___
**The mutation function |
Refactor repeated string interpolation into a utility function.___ **The interpolation of strings for UI text elements is done multiple times with similarparameters. Consider creating a utility function to handle this, reducing redundancy and improving maintainability.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx [91-99]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-dd427743a002e3dad8c75f54ed95a9092983490a56a5fc378a0e3ec2a5d6bdf6R91-R99) ```diff -createNewAccount: interpolateString(textAuth.createNewAccount, locale, customer), -useExistingAccount: interpolateString(textAuth.useExistingAccount, locale, customer), +function getLocalizedText(key) { + return interpolateString(textAuth[key], locale, customer); +} +createNewAccount: getLocalizedText('createNewAccount'), +useExistingAccount: getLocalizedText('useExistingAccount'), ``` | |
Refactor the sign-out function to improve code maintainability and separation of concerns.___ **Refactor thesignOutUserAction function to separate concerns for better maintainability and testing. Currently, the function handles UI routing, state management, and business logic, which can be split into smaller, more manageable functions.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx [136-157]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-4b035f23e367c8645366640c5b6355e6bdd60a52f6a10b88ef9f4f93db8a16ebR136-R157) ```diff -const signOutUserAction = useCallback( - async (error?: boolean) => { - try { - setUserActionLoading(true); - disconnectFromDapp(user.address); - await disconnect(); - let newPathname = pathname.split('/0x')[0]; - if (searchParams?.toString()) { - const params = new URLSearchParams(searchParams.toString()); - newPathname += `?${params.toString()}`; - } - await router.replace(newPathname); - } catch (e) { - console.error('Error signing out', e); - throw e; - } finally { - setUserActionLoading(false); - } - }, - [disconnect], -); +const handleSignOut = useCallback(async () => { + try { + setUserActionLoading(true); + await performSignOut(); + } catch (e) { + console.error('Error during sign out:', e); + throw e; + } finally { + setUserActionLoading(false); + } +}, [performSignOut]); +const performSignOut = useCallback(async () => { + disconnectFromDapp(user.address); + await disconnect(); + await updateRouteAfterSignOut(); +}, [disconnect, user.address, updateRouteAfterSignOut]); + +const updateRouteAfterSignOut = useCallback(() => { + let newPathname = pathname.split('/0x')[0]; + if (searchParams?.toString()) { + const params = new URLSearchParams(searchParams.toString()); + newPathname += `?${params.toString()}`; + } + router.replace(newPathname); +}, [pathname, searchParams, router]); + ``` | |
Refactor repetitive text assignments into a helper function for better maintainability.___ **Consider using a more concise and maintainable approach to handle the state-dependent textassignments by creating a helper function. This function can take the textGate object, locale, and customer as parameters and return the appropriate text based on the offKeyState. This will reduce redundancy and improve code readability.**
[libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.tsx [46-88]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-b04caa7332ebff9c207f545552e87b6297915d203992f9e5bfe4f6569ecd2ed8R46-R88)
```diff
-const textsSubtitle = {
+const getTexts = (textType) => ({
[OffKeyState.Unlocked]: interpolateString(
- textGate.subtitle[OffKeyState.Unlocked],
+ textGate[textType][OffKeyState.Unlocked],
locale,
customer,
),
[OffKeyState.Unlocking]: interpolateString(
- textGate.subtitle[OffKeyState.Unlocking],
+ textGate[textType][OffKeyState.Unlocking],
locale,
customer,
),
...
-};
+});
+const textsSubtitle = getTexts('subtitle');
+const textsMainText = getTexts('mainText');
+
```
| |
Extract repeated setup code into a separate function to reduce code duplication.___ **Refactor the repeated setup code forShopifyWebhookAndApiHandler and mockRequest into a separate function to avoid duplication and improve maintainability.** [libs/integrations/external-api-handlers/src/lib/shopify/index.spec.ts [557-566]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-df93842e018141cf209891b7f7fa3c10fbc063d5eed17ace2701d2d12a234844R557-R566) ```diff -beforeEach(() => { - handler = new ShopifyWebhookAndApiHandler(); - mockRequest = createMockRequest( +function setupHandlerAndRequest() { + const handler = new ShopifyWebhookAndApiHandler(); + const mockRequest = createMockRequest( new URLSearchParams({ address: 'test-address', shop: 'example.myshopify.com', timestamp: Date.now().toString(), signature: 'validSignature', }), ); + return { handler, mockRequest }; +} + +beforeEach(() => { + const { handler, mockRequest } = setupHandlerAndRequest(); }); ``` | |
| Bug |
Normalize address comparisons to prevent case sensitivity issues.___ **Ensure consistent use of string case comparison for addresses. The current implementationuses toLowerCase() inconsistently, which could lead to logical errors or security issues if addresses are compared in a case-sensitive manner elsewhere in the code.** [libs/integrations/external-api-handlers/src/lib/shopify/index.ts [201-205]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-f01dee98100c01117884ab045ae1560ae9e326c3ecf55b3ac4e2f15531a2ef4cR201-R205) ```diff -if (shopifyCustomer && shopifyCustomer.address.toLowerCase() !== ownerAddress.toLowerCase()) { +const normalizedCustomerAddress = shopifyCustomer.address.toLowerCase(); +const normalizedOwnerAddress = ownerAddress.toLowerCase(); +if (shopifyCustomer && normalizedCustomerAddress !== normalizedOwnerAddress) { throw new ForbiddenError('Invalid owner address. The owner address must match the address of the customer.'); } ``` |
| Security |
Sanitize the
___
**Instead of directly using the |
Validate
___
**Add validation to check if the | |
| Performance |
Memoize text objects to improve component performance.___ **To improve the performance of the component, consider memoizing the computed text objects( textsSubtitle, textsMainText, textsKeyStatus) using useMemo hook. This prevents unnecessary recalculations when the component re-renders without changes to its dependencies.** [libs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyGate/OffKeyGate.tsx [46-66]](https://github.com/OfflineHQ/marketplace/pull/301/files#diff-b04caa7332ebff9c207f545552e87b6297915d203992f9e5bfe4f6569ecd2ed8R46-R66) ```diff -const textsSubtitle = { +const textsSubtitle = useMemo(() => ({ [OffKeyState.Unlocked]: interpolateString( textGate.subtitle[OffKeyState.Unlocked], locale, customer, ), ... -}; +}), [textGate, locale, customer]); ``` |
| Robustness |
Add error handling for the
___
**Ensure that the |
Type
enhancement
Description
OffKeyAuthcomponent to handle different customer statuses using the newuseShopifyCustomerhook.useShopifyCustomerhook to manage and fetch customer data, improving the component's responsiveness to state changes.OffKeyProfilecomponent to integrate with theuseShopifyCustomerhook for dynamic UI updates based on customer status.OffKeyHeaderConnectedcomponent to support dynamic text and localization, improving user experience based on customer context.Changes walkthrough
OffKeyAuth.stories.tsx
Add Storybook Stories for OffKeyAuth Componentlibs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.stories.tsx
OffKeyAuthcomponent to demonstrate variousstates and interactions.
authMocksto simulate different authentication states andcustomer data.
OffKeyAuth.tsx
Refactor OffKeyAuth Component for Enhanced State Managementlibs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyAuth/OffKeyAuth.tsx
ShopifyCustomerStatusfor better state management.UI elements.
OffKeyProfile.tsx
Integrate useShopifyCustomer Hook in OffKeyProfile Componentlibs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyProfile/OffKeyProfile.tsx
useShopifyCustomerhook to manage customer data and state.useShopifyCustomer.tsx
Implement useShopifyCustomer Hook for Customer Data Managementlibs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/hooks/useShopifyCustomer.tsx
useShopifyCustomerto fetch and manage customerdata from Shopify.
components.
OffKeyHeaderConnected.tsx
Enhance OffKeyHeaderConnected for Dynamic Text and Localizationlibs/features/unlock/shopify/src/lib/OffKeyHeaderConnected/OffKeyHeaderConnected.tsx
customer data.