search

OntoUML / ontouml-models

The OntoUML/UFO Catalog is a collaborative, structured and open-source catalog of OntoUML and UFO ontology models.
https://w3id.org/ontouml-models/
Other
45 stars 44 forks source link

OntoRights in two versions: Full and Simple #242

Closed JoranL closed 2 years ago

JoranL commented 2 years ago

I am a beginner with GitHub, I hope I have done this right.

I know the instructions states only inlcude one ontology in each pull request, but I thought this could be an exception since they are two versions. Simple OntoRights was derived from Full OntoRights.

pedropaulofb commented 2 years ago

Hi @JoranL, thank you for your contribution.

The instructions indicate that only the most updated version of the ontology (e.g., v1.1 instead of v1.0) is going to be included into the catalog. In your case, seems that the ontologies sent have different scope and requirements and, hence, probably they are eligible to be both included in the catalog (in this case I am going to spit them in two different datasets (i.e., folders)).

I am going to analyze the data you sent up to the end of the next week, ok?

Once again, thank you very much!

JoranL commented 2 years ago

Hello @pedropaulofb,

Yes, they have a different scope as you said.

Thank you for reviewing! Jöran

pedropaulofb commented 2 years ago

@JoranL, I've made a modification to the datasets (folders) you provided. Can you please validate them before I approve the inclusion of the ontologies into the catalog?

1) I made a minor correction on the metadata.yaml file (editorialNote field) so it can be totally compatible with the yaml syntax. 2) Still in the metadata.yaml file, I included your thesis in the source field. 3) I created the references.bib files for both folders.

Thank you in advance.

JoranL commented 2 years ago

@pedropaulofb, thank you for the corrections!

I have looked at the corrections and all looks good. (Please let me know if there is a button I should click to validate technically)

Yes, both ontologies were originally created using the OntoUML-VP Plugin.

No, apart from my master thesis there are still no published works about the ontologies.

Best regards, Jöran

pedropaulofb commented 2 years ago

Two new datasets included into the catalog.

pedropaulofb commented 2 years ago

Thank you very much @JoranL for contributing to the whole OntoUML/UFO community! I'm concluding this PR. Both works were included in the catalog.