Closed bluesteens closed 1 year ago
Triage:
Affected Parties (help determine Sunrise/Sunset):
Affected OCI Artifact
Change Category (Guides Steering Review)
- Steering/Industry Review
- Steering/Industry Notification
4.1 applies to wallet to the degree that ATP VC needs attached. need to be more specific in table or might be covered by API requirements (feed into VRS process), thus remove this row
2.4.2: Consider moving this content to Getting Started Guide. Also, address the "shall".
4.1: Address requirement to adopt GS1 US guideline - may need to identify specific sections that apply to a Wallet solution (where the credential goes).
GS1 LVMS not even mentioned in VRS criteria. why elaborate extensively here? this is not a tutorial document.
work in PR ignored any mentions before section 3, as this will be covered by the intro alignment
July, 27: to be released in Digital Wallet Criteria v3.3.0, interop profile v3.2.0
Steering summary:
Review wallet criteria for sections that suggest that wallets need to adhere to GS1 LWMS in any way that goes beyond delivering credentials to VRS so they can attach them to GS1-defined messages.
Role of VRS (not wallet) As defined in
para 2.4.2.
, VRS need to cater for GS1 LWM, not digital wallets. Hence, any reference to such a requirement should be moved out of the wallet conformance criteria and into newly developed VRS conformance criteria.2.4.2 OCI Credentialing Roles - VRS:
Suggest to move this whole sections into Getting Started and cross-reference. See ticket: https://github.com/Open-Credentialing-Initiative/OCI-Change-Requests/issues/7
Role of wallet = VP provision That said, the wording in
4.1.8 Proofs & Verifications
seems appropriate, as it talks about the provision of VP in the context of LWM. That's all that should be asked of a wallet - to enable VRS to use GS1 LWM by providing VP in a way that is compatible.4.1.8 Proofs & Verifications
Conflicting criteria 4.1 OCI Digital Wallet Standards
Other notable mentions of GS1 std in wallet criteria (may not be a comprehensive list):