Open-Credentialing-Initiative / Digital-Wallet-Conformance-Criteria

Conformance Criteria for Digital Wallets | https://open-credentialing-initiative.github.io/Digital-Wallet-Conformance-Criteria/latest
https://open-credentialing-initiative.github.io/Digital-Wallet-Conformance-Criteria/latest
Apache License 2.0
1 stars 2 forks source link

remove 'blanket SHALL' in section intros #40

Closed bluesteens closed 1 year ago

bluesteens commented 1 year ago

Steering summary

sections start with an overall SHALL but subsections contain SHOULD, MAY, which causes ambiguous requirements and/or an additional superfluous audit test. suggest to remove the blanket SHALL at the start (either remove sentence or capitalization).


4.3 OCI Functional Wallet Features

The following functional requirements (FRs) SHALL be respected by all Digital Wallet Providers.

same goes for 4.4 - the generic intro is superfluous when all sub-criteria have their own granular requirement wording


Triage:

Affected Parties (help determine Sunrise/Sunset):

Affected OCI Artifact

Change Category (Guides Steering Review)

- Steering/Industry Review

- Steering/Industry Notification

Communication

bluesteens commented 1 year ago

replace "expectations" wording in PR with sth that states, "The following is a high-level overview of the technologies used by Digital Wallet Providers as part of this specification:"

bluesteens commented 1 year ago

July, 27: to be released in Digital Wallet Criteria v3.3.0, interop profile v3.2.0