Open-Systems-Pharmacology / Forum

Discussion forum for the Open Systems Pharmacology Project
65 stars 19 forks source link

How can we build permeability limited liver model in PKSIM #700

Closed NileshGaud closed 3 years ago

NileshGaud commented 3 years ago

Dear All,

Is there any option in PKSIM that can be used to build a permeability limited liver model. Most literature suggest using this model for drug transporter related PBPK model building and DDI predictions. Especially when the disposition is governed mainly by uptake and efflux transporters.

StephanSchaller commented 3 years ago

Hi Nilesh, PK-Sim is permeability-limited by default

StephanSchaller commented 3 years ago

See: https://docs.open-systems-pharmacology.org/working-with-pk-sim/pk-sim-documentation/pk-sim-compounds-definition-and-work-flow#adme-properties

And: https://docs.open-systems-pharmacology.org/mechanistic-modeling-of-pharmacokinetics-and-dynamics/modeling-concepts/principles-of-pbpk-modeling#l-adme-logic-and-routes-of-administration

teutonicod commented 3 years ago

Hi @StephanSchaller and @NileshGaud ,

Thanks for the question and the discussion, since I think it is a very interesting topic. I am not sure I would define the model in PK-Sim, "permeability limited". From my understanding this type of definition come from other software, for which the model can be based on one of the two following assumptions:

From my understanding, it is difficult to compare the model, but if we really want to, I would say that in PK-Sim we do not make any of the aforementioned assumptions, but we use both a distribution model and a permeability model to define organ Kp and permeabilities which both drive the distribution of a compound. Which one is more relevant, depends on the molecule phys-chem parameters. I would not define PK-Sim a permeability limited model, since I suppose you could have a parameter set for which the distribution may become limited by perfusion (although I have to say that I never tested the molecule parameter space to check if this is possible).

Donato

StephanSchaller commented 3 years ago

@teutonicod, yes, all what you write is correct and I do agree and thank you for providing this additional detail. Having a case of limitation by perfusion of permeation in PK-Sim depends on the physchem, but structurally, PK-Sim ALWAYS considers permeation. Other PBPK models (often used in e.g. environmental tox) are BY STRUCTURE perfusion limited models. They do not have a concept of permeation and organ subcompartments.

NileshGaud commented 3 years ago

Hi @StephanSchaller and @teutonicod

Thank you for providing the details it really helped me to understand the difference between the two models.

Nilesh

pburkat commented 3 years ago

In the case of highly lipophilicity volatile anesthetics that are inhaled, tissue distribution would be perfusion limited I think.