Closed hahahashen closed 1 month ago
运行截图如下所示
@CodiumAI-Agent /review
⏱️ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4, because the PR introduces a significant amount of new functionality across multiple files, involving complex features like command statistics, time statistics, and server information retrieval. The changes are spread across multiple core components which requires a careful review to ensure compatibility and correctness. |
🧪 Relevant tests | No |
⚡ Possible issues | Possible Bug: The `InfoCmd::DoInitial` method might set `info_section_` without checking if `argc` equals 2 before the check, which could lead to setting the response incorrectly if additional arguments are provided. |
Performance Concern: The method `InfoCmd::InfoCommandStats` iterates over all command statistics and performs calculations on them, which might be inefficient with a large number of commands. | |
🔒 Security concerns | No |
relevant file | src/cmd_thread_pool_worker.cc |
suggestion | Consider using `emplace` directly with constructor arguments instead of creating a temporary `CommandStatistics` object. This avoids the overhead of default constructing an object and then copying over it. [important] |
relevant line | cmdstat_map->emplace(task->CmdName(), statistics); |
relevant file | src/cmd_admin.cc |
suggestion | Instead of using multiple `if` statements to check `argv_[1].data()` against various sections, consider using a `std::map` or `std::unordered_map` to map section strings to `InfoSection` enums. This would make the code cleaner and more scalable if more sections are added in the future. [medium] |
relevant line | } else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kServerSection.data()) == 0) { |
relevant file | src/cmd_admin.cc |
suggestion | To avoid repeated code for appending "\r\n" in `InfoCmd::DoCmd`, consider creating a helper function that appends information followed by "\r\n". This will make the code cleaner and reduce the chance of missing the line break in future modifications. [medium] |
relevant line | info.append("\r\n"); |
relevant file | src/client.cc |
suggestion | Use `std::make_unique` instead of `new` for creating `time_stat_` to ensure exception safety and modern memory management practices. [important] |
relevant line | time_stat_.reset(new TimeStat()); |
@CodiumAI-Agent /improve
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Performance |
Use try_emplace to reduce map lookups___ **Avoid usingfind followed by emplace which can lead to two lookups. Use try_emplace for a single lookup and insertion if not present.** [src/cmd_thread_pool_worker.cc [42-44]](https://github.com/OpenAtomFoundation/pikiwidb/pull/338/files#diff-24a4de80190fd7ed32279732bdadf550a2f7d5f3144f9dfe36ecc2e53d981f8aR42-R44) ```diff -if (cmdstat_map->find(task->CmdName()) == cmdstat_map->end()) { - cmdstat_map->emplace(task->CmdName(), statistics); -} +cmdstat_map->try_emplace(task->CmdName(), statistics); ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: Using `try_emplace` reduces the number of lookups in the map, which improves performance. This suggestion is accurate and provides a clear performance benefit. | 10 |
Best practice |
Use member initializer lists in the copy constructor for efficiency and clarity___ **The copy constructor forCommandStatistics should use member initializer lists for atomic types to ensure that the initialization is more efficient and the intent is clearer.** [src/client.h [25-27]](https://github.com/OpenAtomFoundation/pikiwidb/pull/338/files#diff-2ee628bb1cdcbf04f484b57ea20ddf172db2dfaeb22214ebfb24ff36718a7509R25-R27) ```diff -CommandStatistics(const CommandStatistics& other) { - cmd_time_consuming_.store(other.cmd_time_consuming_.load()); - cmd_count_.store(other.cmd_count_.load()); -} +CommandStatistics(const CommandStatistics& other) : cmd_count_(other.cmd_count_.load()), cmd_time_consuming_(other.cmd_time_consuming_.load()) {} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using member initializer lists in the copy constructor is a best practice that improves efficiency and clarity. This suggestion directly enhances the new code introduced in the PR. | 9 |
Initialize class members in the initializer list___ **Consider initializingtime_stat_ in the constructor initializer list instead of the constructor body for better performance and readability.** [src/client.cc [430]](https://github.com/OpenAtomFoundation/pikiwidb/pull/338/files#diff-4262ef19cc324c0e14881eee2b23dad25b6428d3e2ca1b27f1afcbb7bf5885ecR430-R430) ```diff -time_stat_.reset(new TimeTimeStat()); +PClient::PClient(TcpConnection* obj) : time_stat_(new TimeStat()), parser_(params_) { + auth_ = false; + reset(); +} ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Initializing class members in the initializer list is a best practice in C++ as it can improve performance and readability. This suggestion correctly identifies and addresses this issue. | 8 | |
Add a self-assignment check in the copy constructor to prevent issues___ **Consider checking for self-assignment in the copy constructor ofCommandStatistics to prevent issues when an object is assigned to itself.** [src/client.h [25-27]](https://github.com/OpenAtomFoundation/pikiwidb/pull/338/files#diff-2ee628bb1cdcbf04f484b57ea20ddf172db2dfaeb22214ebfb24ff36718a7509R25-R27) ```diff CommandStatistics(const CommandStatistics& other) { - cmd_time_consuming_.store(other.cmd_time_consuming_.load()); - cmd_count_.store(other.cmd_count_.load()); + if (this != &other) { + cmd_time_consuming_.store(other.cmd_time_consuming_.load()); + cmd_count_.store(other.cmd_count_.load()); + } } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding a self-assignment check is a good practice to prevent potential issues, although it is less critical than using member initializer lists. It is still a valuable improvement. | 8 | |
Use
___
**Use | 6 | |
Maintainability |
Use a map for string comparison to simplify the logic___ **Replace the manual string comparison with a case-insensitive map to simplify the commandsection checking logic and improve maintainability.** [src/client.cc [170-183]](https://github.com/OpenAtomFoundation/pikiwidb/pull/338/files#diff-4262ef19cc324c0e14881eee2b23dad25b6428d3e2ca1b27f1afcbb7bf5885ecR170-R183) ```diff -if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kAllSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoAll; -} else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kServerSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoServer; -} else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kStatsSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoStats; -} else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kCPUSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoCPU; -} else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kDataSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoData; -} else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kRaftSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoRaft; -} else if (strcasecmp(argv_[1].data(), kCommandStatsSection.data()) == 0) { - info_section_ = kInfoCommandStats; +static const std::unordered_map Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using a map for string comparison simplifies the logic and improves maintainability. This suggestion is correct and provides a significant improvement in code readability and maintainability. | 9 |
Possible bug |
Improve the robustness of time calculations in
___
**Replace the manual time calculations in | 7 |
本次更改涉及多个文件,主要增强了命令统计和时间统计功能,改进了服务器信息的检索和显示。通过新增的结构体和方法,程序能够更有效地追踪命令执行的统计数据和时间消耗,从而提供更详尽的系统信息,提升了用户体验。
文件路径 | 变更摘要 |
---|---|
src/client.cc, src/client.h | 添加命令和时间统计功能,新增结构体和相关方法。 |
src/cmd_admin.cc, src/cmd_admin.h | InfoCmd 类增加多个方法,用于动态检索服务器、统计、CPU和命令统计信息。 |
src/cmd_table_manager.cc | 在 GetCmdId 方法后添加一行空语句以改善代码结构。 |
src/pikiwidb.cc, src/pikiwidb.h | 在 PikiwiDB::Init 方法中增加时间设置调用,并新增 Start_time_s 方法以返回启动时间。 |
🐇✨
代码变,功能增,
命令统计入心中。
时间消耗细追踪,
服务器信息更详尽。
兔子欢歌代码舞,
系统性能日日升。
Thank you for using CodeRabbit. We offer it for free to the OSS community and would appreciate your support in helping us grow. If you find it useful, would you consider giving us a shout-out on your favorite social media?
请根据 CodeRabbitai 的改进意见,改进 PR
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
Please improve the PR based on CodeRabbitai’s improvement suggestions
请根据 CodeRabbitai 的改进意见,改进 PR
好的 我稍晚点修改一下
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
Please improve the PR based on CodeRabbitai’s improvement suggestions
Okay, I'll modify it later.
@hahahashen 冲突了,请解决一下
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
@hahahashen There is a conflict, please resolve it
@hahahashen 冲突了,请解决一下
done
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
@hahahashen There is a conflict, please resolve it
done
coderabbitai 留的几个 comment,我觉得还是比较合理的,还请根据 comment 意见继续改进。
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
I think the comments left by coderabbitai are quite reasonable. Please continue to improve based on the comments.
coderabbitai 留的几个 comment,我觉得还是比较合理的,还请根据 comment 意见继续改进。
好的
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
coderabbitai I think the few comments left are quite reasonable. Please continue to improve based on the comments.
OK
coderabbitai 留的几个 comment,我觉得还是比较合理的,还请根据 comment 意见继续改进。
done
Bot detected the issue body's language is not English, translate it automatically.
coderabbitai I think the few comments left are quite reasonable. Please continue to improve based on the comments.
done
误删除了之前那个PR的分支,所以提了一个新的PR,原来PR comment可看 https://github.com/OpenAtomFoundation/pikiwidb/pull/326 ,都进行了回复与处理
Summary by CodeRabbit
新功能
InfoSection
枚举,支持不同信息区域的映射和处理。改进
PClient
类,增加了获取命令统计信息和时间统计的功能。PikiwiDB
类中添加了开始时间的初始化和检索方法。修复
InfoCmd
类的方法以处理不同类型的命令和信息。DoCmd
方法的逻辑,提供更详细的错误处理和信息格式。重构