Defis added with wrong location

[habi]

I've found a cluster of defibrillators with the same, wrong coordinates: https://osm.li/QGR

I'm wondering how these five defibrillators ended up at the same, wrong place.

[chnuessli]

Schauen wir uns an, danke!

[das-g]

result of the overpass query (click to expand)

```json { "version": 0.6, "generator": "Overpass API 0.7.59.1 2a9d9642", "osm3s": { "timestamp_osm_base": "84464", "copyright": "The data included in this document is from www.openstreetmap.org. The data is made available under ODbL." }, "elements": [ { "type": "node", "id": 8563003017, "lat": 46.9399504, "lon": 7.4000000, "tags": { "access": "yes", "defibrillator:location": "im 24-Stundenbereich (bei Bancomat)", "emergency": "defibrillator", "emergency:phone": "144", "indoor": "yes", "opening_hours": "24/7", "operator": "Raiffeisenbank Merenschwand" } }, { "type": "node", "id": 8564112918, "lat": 46.9399504, "lon": 7.4000000, "tags": { "access": "no", "defibrillator:location": "Bauarena Empfang", "description": "während er Öffnungszeiten", "emergency": "defibrillator", "emergency:phone": "144", "indoor": "yes", "opening_hours": "Mo-Fr 09:00 - 18:00; Sa 09:00 - 16:00", "phone": "+41 44 908 55 77" } }, { "type": "node", "id": 8571838626, "lat": 46.9399504, "lon": 7.4000000, "tags": { "access": "yes", "defibrillator:location": "Turnhalle 5736 Burg", "description": "Bei der Schuhwaschanlage", "emergency": "defibrillator", "emergency:phone": "144", "indoor": "no", "opening_hours": "24/7" } }, { "type": "node", "id": 9028654618, "lat": 46.9399504, "lon": 7.4000000, "tags": { "access": "yes", "defibrillator:location": "Forchstrasse 84", "emergency": "defibrillator", "emergency:phone": "144", "indoor": "yes", "opening_hours": "Mo- Fr 08:00-18:00", "operator": "Firma", "phone": "0434883838" } }, { "type": "node", "id": 9076026127, "lat": 46.9399504, "lon": 7.4000000, "tags": { "access": "yes", "defibrillator:location": "Plegeheim St.Otmar", "description": "während 7:00-19:00 Verfügbar", "emergency": "defibrillator", "emergency:phone": "144", "indoor": "yes", "operator": "Pflegeheim St.Otmar", "phone": "0712744711" } } ] } ```

So it's 6 defibrillators allegedly all at "lat": 46.9399504, "lon": 7.4000000, a suspiciously "round" longitude.

[chnuessli]

I've found a cluster of defibrillators with the same, wrong coordinates: https://osm.li/QGR

I'm wondering how these five defibrillators ended up at the same, wrong place.

This was an error in the early versions of the app. In the latest release the user is actively asked to proof the location of the defi. this error shouldn't be triggered anymore.

[chnuessli]

Hello @das-g Do you have the source of your overpass request? I'm interested in this, maybe it helps to identify more clusters?

[habi]

That was my query, specifically geared 'manually' to look a little bit around the location where I found this defi-cluster by chance.

[das-g]

If by "source" you mean the query source code, that's

[out:json][timeout:25];
{{radius=25}}
(
  node["emergency"="defibrillator"](around:{{radius}},{{geocodeCoords:Freiburgstrasse 249b}}); 
);
out body;
>;
out skel qt;

as can be seen on https://osm.li/QGR

[habi]

Here's one more: https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/8717762117/ (also with non-internationalized phone number). According to the defibrillator:location in St. Gallen, but mapped in Bümpliz, close to where the initially reported bunch were...

[chnuessli]

Hello @habi I change this defi... this was over a year ago. From then, several changes should prevent this.

[habi]

https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/8449233017/history was also added at a completely wrong place (and 'survived' two QA sessions there).

[habi]

https://www.openstreetmap.org/node/8850708318/ is also completely wrong. I'm currently trying to find out where to place it correctly.