OpenConext / OpenConext-myconext

A (guest) IdP for OpenConext
https://eduid.nl/
4 stars 7 forks source link

As a user logging into a service requiring MFA, I want to be told clearly that I must use the eduID app every step #165

Closed FlorisFokkinga closed 1 year ago

FlorisFokkinga commented 1 year ago

This screen is rather clear: 'to proceed to you must '

image

If the user chooses to ignore this warning or, perhaps, doesn't read all this text, the next screen is less clear.

image

'Login without the eduApp is strongly discouraged.' While it is impossble, like the previous screen said. 'The will not receive your attributes'. Most people have no idea what this means. It means you cannot login to the service.

If the user continues anyway, the next screen is just wrong. It's not the user's institution that denies access.

image

To be clear: the problem is not that logging in doesn't work, but that after ignoring the first warning, the warnings and errors become less clear and accurate.

thijskh commented 1 year ago

Also the word "eduApp" just appears out of nowhere in the second screen.