What is the our Python import preference?

[odscjames]

A)

import os
...
x = os.path.join(...)

B)

from os.path import join
...
x = join(...)

Discuss!

I think I prefer A? It makes it clearer when reading code what is being called, without having to check the imports, which might be a long way away from the code.

I don't think PEP8 covers this? (It says prefer on separate lines, prefer absolute imports where possible, and no wild card (*) imports).

[BibianaC]

In the case of os, I prefer A.

If it would be something else like datetime I would prefer: from datetime import datetime (or any other)

instead of import datetime and then having to do datetime.datetime

[odscjames]

Is there some rules you have for when you prefer A or B?

I've just found issues with circular imports when using type B and now I think I need to go and read up more on how Python imports work, as I'm clearly missing some details!

[BibianaC]

This gist might help https://gist.github.com/datagrok/40bf84d5870c41a77dc6 In terms of style you can also read Pep8 https://www.python.org/dev/peps/pep-0008/#imports

[odscjames]

That's an interesting read, thanks!

As far as I can tell, PEP8 doesn't cover my original question. There is a section on "When importing a class from a class-containing module, ...." that touches on this, but it doesn't actually express a preference!