FFE - OSM NUTS-3 regions 2013 (generalized)

OpenEnergyPlatform / data-preprocessing

Repository for data formatting, import of data, data and metadata review, and data curation.

GNU Affero General Public License v3.0

10 stars 7 forks source link

FFE - OSM NUTS-3 regions 2013 (generalized) #3

Closed Ludee closed 4 years ago

Ludee commented 6 years ago

Contributed data set: derived OSM NUTS-3 regions.

2018-04-25 Received review request via mail
2018-04-26 Received data via OEP-API
2018-04-27 Received metadata string via mail
2018-04-30 Add metadata string and data to review process
2018-05-08 Data published with version 'v1' at boundaries.ffe_osm_nut3

Link to metadata: https://github.com/OpenEnergyPlatform/data-preprocessing/blob/master/data-review/boundaries.ffe_osm_nuts3.sql

EDIT: This is the "first official data review" in the OEP. See #2 for general information.

Ludee commented 6 years ago

Metadata string passed the review with minor changes in style and content. Data review will follow as soon as access rights are granted. @MGlauer please grant owner on _sandbox.osmnuts3 to oeuser.

Ludee commented 6 years ago

Inconsistent use of English: {"name": "geom", "description": "Generalisierte Geometrie", "unit": "none"}

Added "deu" to languages. Other option is to translate column description.

Ludee commented 6 years ago

2018-05-08 Access rights have been granted

data types: id serial version text nuts_code varchar(5) geom geometry(MultiPolygon,3035)

Ludee commented 6 years ago

It is missing which version of the sources (OSM and BKG) were used. There is a inconsistency between the (two) copyrights from the (two) sources and the instructions.

L: "instruction": "In addition to the copyright of the Forschungsstelle für Energiewirtschaft e.V. (FfE) (www.ffe.de), the following sources must be cited: © OpenStreetMap-Mitwirkende (https://www.openstreetmap.org/copyright), © GeoBasis-DE / BKG 2016 Daten verändert" "copyright": "© FfE"

The instructions only deal with the attribution. All other aspects of the license are not considered. Also see: https://tldrlegal.com/license/odc-open-database-license-%28odbl%29

Ludee commented 6 years ago

Geometry check passed! No invalid geometries.

Ludee commented 6 years ago

Include feedback:

Include description about reference year
Include description about data manipulation steps
Change year of download from Geofabrik

Ludee commented 6 years ago

Data set available here: http://www.openenergyplatform.org/dataedit/view/boundaries/ffe_osm_nuts3

christian-rli commented 5 years ago

Whille a comprehensive description of the review process is still missing , this "first official data review" appears to be completed. Can this issue be closed? Issue #2 may still reference it when closed.

christian-rli commented 4 years ago

The comprehensive description of the review process is now available. No further tasks seem to be open. Therefore closing this issue.