search

OpenLiberty / liberty-language-server

The Liberty Config Language Server provides language server features for Liberty server configuration files through any of the supported client IDEs.
Eclipse Public License 2.0
5 stars 11 forks source link

Completion does not replace text typed by user #276

Open turkeylurkey opened 4 months ago

turkeylurkey commented 4 months ago

When editing bootstrap.properties in some cases completion replaces all of the text I type but in others it leaves some text behind and creates an invalid key. Tested using VS Code and Liberty Tools version v24.0.3.

The correct result: type "com.ibm.ws.log" and select the first result and the key "com.ibm.ws.logging.apps.write.json" is added. image image

Then erase part of the key so that only "com.ibm.ws.log" is showing and select the first result. "com.ibm.ws.com.ibm.ws.logging.apps.write.json" is added. image image

This seems like a bug.

cherylking commented 4 months ago

Interesting, I would like to know if the same behavior is seen in Eclipse. I'm wondering if the problem could be with the data sent from VS Code to LCLS in the second request.

scottkurz commented 4 months ago

It looks like it works fine on Eclipse with 24.0.3 (actually an internal build of our next release). I deleted my recording but will try to post a new one at some point.

cherylking commented 4 months ago

Thanks Scott. So if it works in Eclipse, I think it is unlikely that it is a problem in LCLS. However, the fix may still be in LCLS to accommodate for whatever data is coming from VS Code that leads to the problem. We will have to compare the data that is coming in on the two requests and see what is different. I will mark this as a bug. It will be a low priority though.

TrevCraw commented 4 months ago

This issue came up when working on integrating the latest LSP4IJ for LT IntelliJ. VS Code was tried as a comparison: https://github.com/redhat-developer/lsp4ij/issues/270#issuecomment-2088292926

cherylking commented 4 months ago

We use the constructor for CompletionItem that takes a String, which is our property key and gets set as the label in CompletionItem. The suggestion in the referenced issue by Trevor is to use TextEdit instead of passing the property key as the label. There is a method setTextEdit on CompletionItem. Will have to investigate using that instead of the label for the key.