OpenSourceMycetoma / Series-1-Fenarimols

Open Source Mycetoma's First Series of Molecules
10 stars 3 forks source link

Megathread of all MycetOS Fenarimol compounds – future, current, finished and halted compounds #29

Open fantasy121 opened 4 years ago

fantasy121 commented 4 years ago

Following our meeting on 29th April 2020, I will start this issue thread where we can have an up-to-date list of fenarimol compounds, until we can find a better solution. @bendndi Can you put a comment below this with the most up-to-date list of compound progress? And can you please update this list by replacing the image with a newer version of the image instead of making a new comment (this is to reduce clutter on this thread).

Everyone else, please limit comments to this thread to update on your progress only. That is:

To reduce clutter, no suggestions, recommendations, discussions are to be posted here, only synthetic progress. Please send those to the other threads in this repository such as the Sevenoaks thread, the Open Synthesis Network thread and Hung's PhD thread.

The order of things to appear in this thread is as follows:

Please consult @bendndi requirements below before commenting to help make it easier for him to update this file

bendndi commented 4 years ago

Up to date Fenarimol list (20th Oct 2020): image image image image image

bendndi commented 4 years ago

Thanks @fantasy121

To help me keep this file updated, please use the following guidelines:

To notify me of componuds you plan to synthesize please make a post in which you list the compounds as either:

If you have completed synthesis on a compound from the above list:

If you have run into issues and believe the compound cannot be readily synthesized

(Hint on obtaining SMILES strings: in Marvin Sketch you can highlight a componud and hit "Cntrl + L" to copy as SMILES; in chemdraw / biovia draw you can "Generate text from structure" in the Chemistry drop down menus". If you still have issues putting in SMILES then you can post as drawing of structure but please note this is considerably more work to add into the data base (requires re-sketching of each compound by hand rather than a simple copy/paste of the SMILES string list)

bendndi commented 4 years ago

To help me get the list above up to date, can everyone please post below the componuds they have successfully synthesized, are currently working on, or would like to add to the target list (ideally as smiles strings but in this first instance a single image of structures is also fine if this is less work on your side) @fantasy121 @dmitrij176 @mattodd @mattodowd25

dmitrij176 commented 4 years ago

Synthesis update May 2020 

bendndi commented 4 years ago

@dmitrij176 Any chance you're able to share this as a SMILES list e.g. an excel table with smiles column, status colum and ID column? It is much easier and quicker to handle SMILES than having to resketch compounds by had each time. (I can help you get the SMILES strings if you can tell me which drawing package you're using)

fantasy121 commented 4 years ago

20200519 11 Compounds  GitHub Update Format

Name: Hung Phat Duong Institution: University of Sydney Location: Australia

Already on OSN list:

Done: HPD035-1P6 — P4_D_MXF004 HPD037-1 — P4_D_MXF005

Scheduled: HPD042-1 — P4_D_MXF006

Difficult (Stopped) HPD036-2 — P4_D_MXF009

Not on OSN list:

Done: HPD033-3P3 — BrC(C=C1)=CC=C1C(C2CCCCC2)(O)C3=CN=CC=C3 HPD033-2P4 — OC(CCCC)(C1=CC=C(Br)C=C1)C2=CN=CC=C2

Scheduled: HPD034-4 — OC(C1CCCC1)(C2=CC=C(Br)C=C2)C3=CN=CC=C3 HPD031-2 — ClC(C=C1)=CC=C1C(C2=CC=CC=C2)(O)C3=CC=CC=C3Br HPD032-2 — ClC(C=C1)=CC=C1C(C2CCCCC2)(O)C3=CC=CC=C3Br HPD041-2 — OC(C1=CC=C(Br)C=C1)(C2=CC=C(Cl)C=C2)C3=CC=CC=C3 HPD043-1 — OC(C1=CC=C(Br)C=C1)(C2=CC=C(Cl)C=C2)C3=CN=CC=C3

@bendndi Can you change the "synthesised by" line for me from "HDong" to "HDuong", it's missing a "u". Thanks.

wwjvdsande commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 . We received the compounds for screening. Could you sent us the molecular weights so that we can make the proper dilutions for screening? We could screen them tomorrow if we have this informaiton

wwjvdsande commented 4 years ago

@dmitrij176 we are screening your compounds as well. Hopefully we have some update soon on the activity of these compounds. We are now screening a high and low dose to see which are the most potent ones.

mattodd commented 4 years ago

Hi @wwjvdsande it's great to hear you're back and in lab. Thanks for the update and looking forward to those new data! Hope all goes well.

wwjvdsande commented 4 years ago

Hi @mattodd yes we have started up slowly. Not all systems are running yet, but the in vitro susceptibility testing has started. We are not back full-time yet but are starting up the most essential experiments.

bendndi commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 I'm adding in your compounds from this post and for HPD033-3P3 the image shows it as a chlorophenyl but the smiles shos it as a bromophenyl - could you please confirm which one it is?

bendndi commented 4 years ago

List updated to reflect most recent changes

fantasy121 commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 I'm adding in your compounds from this post and for HPD033-3P3 the image shows it as a chlorophenyl but the smiles shos it as a bromophenyl - could you please confirm which one it is?

I've corrected my drawings. The SMILES were correct. Also for HPD34-4 as well as theseare related

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 I see you have been having issues oxidizing a precursor alcohol to it's ketone using manganese - have you tried Hypervalent Iodine oxidants like PIDA or DMP?

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@dmitrij176 I found a possibly useful paper when doing research into perfumery: https://orgmedchemlett.springeropen.com/track/pdf/10.1186/2191-2858-1-12

facile synthesis of oximes using solvent free methods

dmitrij176 commented 4 years ago

@dmitrij176 I found a possibly useful paper when doing research into perfumery: https://orgmedchemlett.springeropen.com/track/pdf/10.1186/2191-2858-1-12

facile synthesis of oximes using solvent free methods

Thank you @MFernflower

fantasy121 commented 4 years ago

@MFernflower I had DMP as a potential alternative should MnO2 oxidation not working. Benefit of MnO2 is that it is quite cheap, readily available and easy to handle. I actually had it working for me quite well a few years back but am unsure as to why it stops working now. So currently doing some testing to see whether it's the problem with the starting ketones or with the MnO2 reagent itself. Testing old ketone vs new ketones, and testing my bottle of MnO2 vs borrowed MnO2 from another group. I will also be ordering some new activated MnO2 to see if that solves my problem.

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 it appears the ketone is commercially available under the unusual moniker of 3-Benzoylpyridine

Might be worth buying to avoid the annoying task of oven drying inorganic reagents!

fantasy121 commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 it appears the ketone is commercially available under the unusual moniker of 3-Benzoylpyridine Might be worth buying to avoid the annoying task of oven drying inorganic reagents!

Thanks @MFernflower - Great suggestion. I think I initially avoided this option as I expected the conversion to be easy (from personal experience) but if this one keeps giving me problems definitely I will get it commercially.

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 triphenylmethanol might not be a bad thing to send with the two other compounds that have had the pyridine removed to wendy

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@kym834 I hate to be that guy but would it be possible to post an overview of the fenarimol compounds you will be making?

kym834 commented 4 years ago

Hi All, From the list above I've made plans to synthesis the following compounds and I would like to put my name down for them P4_A_009 P4_A_010 P4_B_008 P4_B_011 P4_B_012

Sydney, Australia / Kymberley Scroggie / University of Sydney

bendndi commented 4 years ago

Thanks @kym834 - list at top of page updated to reflect this.

dmitrij176 commented 4 years ago
image

Synthesis update: The two analogs DM27-1 and DM28-1 have been successfully synthesised. @bendndi could you please update the OSN list.

fantasy121 commented 4 years ago

20200921ProposedBrBzRxn Products Additional compounds that I'm planning to make.

I will also claim P4_D_MXF007 from the OSN list

Typo correction from previous update. 20200519 11 Compasdsadounds  GitHub Update Fsormat HPD033-2P4 should contain an extra Br- as depicted Corrected SMILES string: OC(CCCC)(C1=CN=CC=C1)C2=CC=C(Br)C=C2

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 If i'm not mistaken ripping off the pyridine ring will cause the compound to become inactive but hey more data is more data

bendndi commented 4 years ago

@fantasy121 @MFernflower Indeed, pretty much the only thing we can say for certain about the SAR of fenarimols is the losing that 3-pyridiyl will remove CYP51 inhibition and therefore is hgihly likely (read: almost certain) to kill any anti-fungal activity. i'd mkae one example to confirm this, or I'd make the hindered 2-methyl or 6-methyl pyrdine analogue to prove this point, but I wouldn't prioritize a suite of such compounds.

MFernflower commented 4 years ago

@bendndi @fantasy121 @mattodd

Removing the nitrogen prevents the molecule from binding the iron atom in the cyp51 active site

cyp51_active_site

mattodd commented 4 years ago

Agreed @bendndi. @fantasy121 I'd make one Ph analog for now and combine the joined-ring analogs with the Pyr.

fantasy121 commented 3 years ago

2020OctNov - GitHub propose pt 2 Updated list of compounds I'm planning to make. Removing non-pyridyl compounds apart from a small batch I completed. Looking more into aliphatic ring conversion which reduces LogD values (inspiration from HPD033-3P3).

fantasy121 commented 3 years ago

Agreed @bendndi. @fantasy121 I'd make one Ph analog for now and combine the joined-ring analogs with the Pyr.

Thanks. I've completed one of the Pyr + joined-ring analogues done and sent. The other joined-in analgoue is a dead-end.

MFernflower commented 3 years ago

@fantasy121 looks good - might I ask if you could try reacting dicyclohexylketone with the pyridine lithium?

dmitrij176 commented 3 years ago

Ghana OSN compounds

@wwjvdsande @mattodd @bendndi 10 compounds from the University of Ghana along with my 2 novel analogues DM27-1 and DM28-1 were dispatched to Rotterdam yesterday. @wwjvdsande they are scheduled for delivery on Monday, so in case of any post issues please let me know.

dmitrij176 commented 3 years ago

@wwjvdsande compound coding error in A06 and A07 has been resolved and labels changed accordingly to match the MW values in the attached scheme.

fantasy121 commented 3 years ago

@fantasy121 looks good - might I ask if you could try reacting dicyclohexylketone with the pyridine lithium?

I'll get to it once this batch is done as I need to order it and it might take a bit of time. Reactants for the ones I'm planning to do now are more accessible. Will update when I get to that point.

bendndi commented 3 years ago

2020OctNov - GitHub propose pt 2 Updated list of compounds I'm planning to make. Removing non-pyridyl compounds apart from a small batch I completed. Looking more into aliphatic ring conversion which reduces LogD values (inspiration from HPD033-3P3).

Hi @fantasy121 , would it be possible for you to send me this list as a table of SMILES strings like below? Makes it so much easier than uploading each structure by hand (30 seconds instead of 30 minutes)

image

bendndi commented 3 years ago

Updated the OSN list to reflect UofGhana compiunds. Will update again with new molecules from @fantasy121 if I can get the smiles (may take longer for me to get around to it if I update by hand)

Wilson-Lm commented 3 years ago

Hi @dmitrij176 We have received your compounds! It arrived yesterday as mentioned. Also noted on the compound coding error for A06 and A07.

@fantasy121 @dmitrij176 One question which is also wise to have a think before our next meeting, Do we want to standardise the names for the compounds that were synthesised for the 2020 fenarimol manuscript? We currently have HPD-, DM- and LR-. Would it be easier if they have a similar coding system? What do you all think?

bendndi commented 3 years ago

@Wilson-Lm Typically in a manuscript with a large range of compounds such as this one, the standard approach is to just number to componuds rather than use trivial names. e.g. 1, 2, 3...

bendndi commented 3 years ago

We did discuss earlier about have a standardised MycetOS numbering system. I still believe this is a good idea (and should be a standardised process across the project). There was an issue thread on this at the start of MycetOS but I can no longer see it.

mattodd commented 3 years ago

@bendndi @Wilson-Lm YES PLEASE, we need to use the standardised numbering system. Internal codes are fine internally, but not when we start sending compounds around for evaluation and discussing them here together. The numbering method is here, and needs to be used in conjunction with the Master List, so that compounds do not receive duplicate numbers. It looks like we have not numbered any of these compounds properly, is that right @fantasy121 ? In which case let's make a start with your compounds up the top of the sheet.

Wilson-Lm commented 3 years ago

"compound coding error in A06 and A07 has been resolved and labels changed accordingly to match the MW values in the attached @scheme."

@dmitrij176 , I just want to double confirm the compounds before reconstituting and discarding the original bottle. is the information below correct? A06 - mass, 68.68mg; MW, 319.13 A07 - mass 38.03; MW, 347.18

dmitrij176 commented 3 years ago

"compound coding error in A06 and A07 has been resolved and labels changed accordingly to match the MW values in the attached @scheme."

@dmitrij176 , I just want to double confirm the compounds before reconstituting and discarding the original bottle. is the information below correct? A06 - mass, 68.68mg; MW, 319.13 A07 - mass 38.03; MW, 347.18

Hi Wilson. Yes, thats right. I have double checked all the samples and can confirm that there is a full match between all data points.

Wilson-Lm commented 3 years ago

Thank you! @dmitrij176

wwjvdsande commented 3 years ago

@bendndi @Wilson-Lm YES PLEASE, we need to use the standardised numbering system. Internal codes are fine internally, but not when we start sending compounds around for evaluation and discussing them here together. The numbering method is here, and needs to be used in conjunction with the Master List, so that compounds do not receive duplicate numbers. It looks like we have not numbered any of these compounds properly, is that right @fantasy121 ? In which case let's make a start with your compounds up the top of the sheet.

@mattodd @bendndi @fantasy121 @dmitrij176 @Wilson-Lm is there a list were the "renumbering of the old names" into the official names is deposited? For us non-chemists it is a bit difficult to do the renumbering. We need to add the official names to the figures and tables when drafting the manuscript. We currently still use the numbers on the compounds received.

dmitrij176 commented 3 years ago

Good day @bendndi and @mattodd. I am writing to inform you that the work on novel Fenarimol coding in the Master List is complete. All molecules have been assigned with unique codes. I am just reconfirming few entries with @fantasy121. I want to make sure that everything is correct before project members start to use MYOS numbering in research papers, drafts etc. The only thing which I wasnt sure was the presence of Cetirizine.HCl in the MYOS Compounds List. The mentioned molecule is a marketed antihistamine drug but it looks like it has been tested previously. Has it been resynthesised and then tested? Finally, is it supposed to be in that list if its not novel? Can someone please clarify. Thank you in advance

fantasy121 commented 3 years ago

@dmitrij176 Mat brought to my attention Cetirizine was available for purchase and we agreed it would be interesting to see its activity. This compound was evaluated but was not synthesised by me. In the context of mycetoma, Cetirizine is novel in the sense that it hasn't been tested before, but not that it is a new molecule that hasn't been synthesised before. I think all information is good information and we should have Cetirizine in with the data as well.