search

OpenStemmata / database

An open database of stemmata
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
13 stars 12 forks source link

Vie de Saint Alexis #22

Closed gabays closed 3 years ago

gabays commented 3 years ago

Vie de Saint Alexis. Zufferey proposes a stemma but Perugi refuses to draw one. Contini proposes another one. What do we do with that? Plus: there are some empty nodes I do not really know how to handle…

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

AND Gaston Paris ;)

We do one folder (DOT file, metadata, image) for each edition ?

In my personal database, that I should definitely PR soon to avoid redundancy, I have entered Zufferey, and not Paris.

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

Should we have a «Reference stemma» label for the stemmata that are considered as best for each text ?

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

@gabays : also, the one I got in my database is an updated version of this one, by the same Zufferey (2010)

https://doi.org/10.3406/roma.2010.7270

Do you want to switch to this newer one ? Do we keep both ?

gabays commented 3 years ago

Mmm… This idea of reference stemma is seductive, but it might drag us into complex discussions and choices when people disagree… What would be a use case for such a label? Do we really need to decide?

And if you have an updated version, please publish this one rather than mine. No worries! But do publish your personal database, so that we avoid problems like that, yes!

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

Let's publish both ;)