adding Isopet - Githubissues

gabays commented 3 years ago

Hello JB and Gus,

Attempt to add Marie de France's Isopet to the database. Result is not perfect: somme problems remain (ms name with a question mark for instance).

Let me know what you think for a first attempts,

Simon

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

Hey, many thanks Simon !

I'd stick to the same extension for all DOT files (I used dot and you gv; first one seems more obvious, but I might miss something);

In the DOT file

I think the specification of hypothetical nodes is missing, as in
```
omega[color="grey", label="Ω"]
0[color="grey"]
```
etc.
I think 0 should actually be O. And we're reserving numbers only for unlabelled nodes in the source.
beta¹ -> L; should be beta¹ -> B; I think.
for question marks and Greek Letters, you can do Z[label="Z?"] and omega[color="grey", label="Ω"], (and gamma2/L?, etc.)

I see you're not going for easy stemmata !

On the metadata

rootType: either you're keeping Warnke omega (and then root is original, as shown, which is probably the way to go); or you remove omega, and root is archetype (the ACTUAL situation, but not the own drawn). Not sure it is clear ?

gabays commented 3 years ago

Regarding 0, the stemma is totally shitty… There are two 0s…

regarding hypothetical nodes, I missed something I guess: where are the guidelines? There is another color for that?

Regarding the extension, it is the one offered by Edotor

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

Do not hesitate to make suggestions if it is unclear.

Two O's, zut ! You can print them both as O with Obis[label="O"] for instance.

Regarding the extension, it is the one offered by Edotor It's a detail, but do we switch to .gv then? @GusRiva

GusRiva commented 3 years ago

Apparently, GraphViz actually recommends the .gv extension here, so I would say we go for that.

Jean-Baptiste-Camps commented 3 years ago

@gabays : two last corrections, if you don't mind ;)

OpenStemmata / database