List all modes - Githubissues

OpenTransport / vocabulary

A vocabulary to describe transport systems

36 stars 9 forks source link

List all modes #4

Open pietercolpaert opened 10 years ago

pietercolpaert commented 10 years ago

Problem

GTFS and Transmodel have a different list of all public transport modes. We want a list of all transport modes (public and private).

Solution

[ ] Decide on a list for public transport: GTFS or Transmodel?
[x] agree on a list for private transport

Issues can be created if a transport mode would not be present in the current list.

Tristramg commented 10 years ago

I’d say we create our own list, that would be a merge of GTFS and Transmodel

pietercolpaert commented 10 years ago

We haven't found the transmodel list... Does it even exist?

Let's go for the GTFS list and extend it over time?

stifoon commented 10 years ago

Transmodel doesn't limit TransportMode. But NEPTUNE implementation of Transmodel does ;-)

http://www.normes-donnees-tc.org/spip.php?rubrique17

In "trident_Global_schema.xsd" form NEPTUNE xsd, you got:

"Air" "Train" "LongDistanceTrain" "LongDistanceTrain_2" "LocalTrain" "RapidTransit" "Metro" "Tramway" "Coach" "Bus" "Ferry" "Waterborne" "PrivateVehicle" "Walk" "Trolleybus" "Bicycle" "Shuttle" "Taxi" "VAL" "Other"

stifoon commented 10 years ago

Another mode list from NETEX standard (http://www.normes-donnees-tc.org/IMG/pdf/Specifications_Echange_Netex_v1-0-2.pdf)

air rail intercityRail urbanRail metro tram coach bus water selfDrive trolleyBus taxi unknown

to feed the issue :)

Always too many mode (why trolleybus?) but no distinction between walk, bike or car (selfDrive)