search

OpenWIS / openwis

http://openwis.github.io/openwis
GNU General Public License v3.0
11 stars 15 forks source link

issue with harvesting/synch from Tokyo for "unassociated" metadata #195

Open woollattd opened 8 years ago

woollattd commented 8 years ago

I have been informed by DWD that Tokyo are looking after the Unassociated Metadata and not them any more. (previously WIMMS)

I am trying to set up a harvest and synch task. with this URL http://www.wis-jma.go.jp/meta/oaiprovider.jsp?verb=ListSets

I am expecting to see 'WIS-UNASSOCIATED' to set up metadata harvest but OpenWIS doesn’t see what it should, it sees something called ‘WIS centres not yet associated’ rather than WIS-UNASSOCIATED tokyo-1

-on JMA-Portal. If you scroll down under: WIS_Center(OAI_Set), you find WIS-UNASSOCIATED tokyo-2

Maybe OpenWIS picks up the wrong titles somehow. As, for example, we can see also ‘Metadata from GISC at Seoul’ rather than WIS-GISC-SEOUL as I would expect. What is it doing?

These titles appear on the Tokyo page http://www.wis-jma.go.jp/cms/metadata/oai-pmh/

not sure how it's picking those up?

NOTE: Synch doesn’t see anything in the drop down after a 'fetch'! So can’t set up a synch task. tokyo-0

6a6d74 commented 6 years ago

@SungsooDO - contact TT-GISC (Ken Tsunoda) to ask about getting the 3000+ metadata records in the WIS-UNASSOCIATED category properly assigned to the appropriate GISC.

6a6d74 commented 6 years ago

(close this action once WIS-UNASSOCIATED category is empty

SungsooDO commented 6 years ago

I asked GISC Tokyo about WIS-UNASSOCIATED and please see below, reply from Tokyo As of now 4 GISC(Pretoria, Casablanca, Washington, New Delhi) is not providing OAI server. In case of GISC Seoul, it's not harvesting WIS-UNASSOCIATED from Tokyo.

======================================================== Dear Sungsoo,

Thank you for asking Ken about OAI-SET in GISC Tokyo. My name is Shuichi Ikeda, I'm in charge of Metadata management of GISC Tokyo. So I would like to answer your question instead of Ken.

So do we still need to set up metadata harvest of WIS-UNASSOCIATED? or don't need to harvest it?

You need to harvest WIS-UNASSOCIATED until remaining four GISCs start providing/managing metadata in its AoR.

Do you have future plan to make it empty or delete this OAI set?

Yes, we have a plan to delete that OAI set after remaining four GISCs start providing/managing metadata in its AoR.

If you have additional question about metadata, please feel free to contact me. Keeping in touch.

with best regards, Shuichi Ikeda GISC Tokyo

woollattd commented 6 years ago

due to #292 I am currently unable to check whether the original issue occurs. I suspect it might. Have Tokyo been asked about that and/or have we checked OpenWIS code yet to determine where the issue sits?

6a6d74 commented 6 years ago

@SungsooDO - thank you for checking this.

I find it interesting that 4 GISCs are not offering an OAI server; more so given that Washington, New Delhi and Casablanca all use OpenWIS (not sure about Pretoria) so it should be a matter of configuration to expose this service.

I think the best course of action is to raise this issue with TT-GISC.

As I am not a member of TT-GISC, are you able to do this? e.g. ask TT-GISC what measures / actions are in place to encourage the remaining four GISCs to expose their OAI server.

Thank you.