search

OrleansContrib / Orleankka

Functional API for Microsoft Orleans http://orleanscontrib.github.io/Orleankka
Apache License 2.0
495 stars 76 forks source link

Orleankka Support for Azure Gateway without using Cloud Services ? #101

Closed johnkattenhorn closed 8 years ago

johnkattenhorn commented 8 years ago

We've recently move away from Cloud Services to TopShelf implemented exe's to allow us to deploy more rapidly.

If we configure to use Gateway Ports etc. everything connects up but I couldn't figure out why I couldn't just continue to use the Azure Gateway type without using AzureClientConfigurator / AzureServerConfigurator as they have a dependency on AzureSilo ?

I've had a dig through the source and I can see the AzureSilo is doing a bunch of additional work. So I thought I'd stop and ask if this is a supported configuration.

If it is support then the outlining code configuration settings for the silo and the client would be much appreciated.

NB. I've checked out the ServiceFabric Azure @ReubenBond built as that works he set's a bunch of settings on the SiloHost manually and I don't think I can get to the underlying SiloHost inside Orleankka can I ?

I've also asked this question over at the Orleans repo to see if it is a supported situation from an Orleans perspective.

AntyaDev commented 8 years ago

@yevhen what do you think?

johnkattenhorn commented 8 years ago

@AntyaDev - It seems from an Orleans perspective is should be possible but still waiting for some more guidance, here is the issue I raised over there 👍

https://github.com/dotnet/orleans/issues/1811

AntyaDev commented 8 years ago

@johnkattenhorn :+1:

yevhen commented 8 years ago

Hi @johnkattenhorn

Ye, I'll update api to make it possible to work with/without cloud services. At Youscan we use custom setup hosting Orleans in YAMS, which is itself hosted in Cloud Service. I remember I still owe to write a blog post on our YAMS setup. Willl get to this soon.

yevhen commented 8 years ago

Fixed by https://github.com/OrleansContrib/Orleankka/commit/e296745bc9eceb75cbabef65c8d287b2136599b1 and sample configuration is added by https://github.com/OrleansContrib/Orleankka/commit/e9e770cf7ddb2f9011e9ea6ff4924697705db9f9

Next version of Orleankka won't have dedicated Azure package. We won't hide Orleans and all of the azure configuration could be done with ClientConfiguration