Closed huard closed 4 years ago
I was thinking the same thing when I saw the email. There's more than a few here that are already in xclim. I'm familiar with the methods for the agroclimate indicators (GDD, CHU, CDD) and wanted to integrate them anyway.
Plusieurs de ces indicateurs font partie de l’Atlas agroclimatique du Québec. Suite à l’évaluation de l’atlas, les usagers nous on demander la possibilité d’utiliser des seuils différents. Par exemple : pour Frost days ( 0deg C) – garder le seuil de 0 mais inclure la provision pour utiliser une autre température gélive, pour Growing Degree Days – garder 5,10, 15 deg C mais inclure la provision pour utiliser une autre température gélive C’est peut-être déjà, sinon je vous garantis que l’effort additionnel sera rentable.
Hélène
Hélène Côté, MSc Spécialiste Groupe Simulations et analyses climatiques Ouranos 550, Sherbrooke ouest, 19e étage, tour ouest Montréal, Qc, CANADA H3A 1B9 http://www.ouranos.ca/
Consultez le document de synthèse « Vers l’adaptation » https://www.ouranos.ca/synthese-2015/
De : Trevor James Smith notifications@github.com Répondre à : Ouranosinc/xclim reply@reply.github.com Date : jeudi 8 novembre 2018 à 13:08 À : Ouranosinc/xclim xclim@noreply.github.com Cc : Subscribed subscribed@noreply.github.com Objet : Re: [Ouranosinc/xclim] PCC indicators (#103)
I was thinking the same thing when I saw the email. There's more than a few here that are already in xclim. I'm familiar with the methods for the agroclimate indicators (GDD, CHU, CDD) and wanted to integrate them anyway.
— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/Ouranosinc/xclim/issues/103#issuecomment-437099560, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AJS68rW2z2XjHowfdJLFuchwwqEdyq2Iks5utHL_gaJpZM4YVMqQ.
Bien reçu, les seuils sont paramétrables.
@cothel Pourrais-tu créer un issue avec la liste des indicateurs de l'atlas pour qu'on garde ça dans notre liste d'épicerie ?
Most of these seem pretty doable, and would increase usability of XCLIM (both independantly and via PAVICS). We already have matlab code for Corn Heat Units and other agroclimat atlas variables to start from
I realize it's shameless self-promotion, but these are a few others that could be interesting to add in https://github.com/Zeitsperre/wine-climatology. The scripts are written for PyQGIS, but the methods are clear in the literature.
Not having to handle the calendar-based resampling with xarray makes these much easier to write out.
Document avec les calculs / defintions de l'atlas agropclimatique http://www.agrometeo.org/atlas/display_guide/Formules_atlas_agroclim_2012_v10.docx
Excellent ! Travis, veux-tu mettre un milestone là-dessus ? Genre 1.2 ?
1.2 engage!
@huard Would you be interested in me working on this in the next few weeks?
@Zeitsperre My sense of priorities is a bit off at the moment, but I would rather spend efforts on cleaning the THREDDS server's content. Additional indicators can be added on an as the need arise basis.
@Zeitsperre I suggest here we create a mock module (similar to ICCLIM), with this list of indices. Seems like a low-hanging fruit.
I'm not convinced that this is really that useful unless we start coding the missing indicators (mostly for agricultural applications from what I see). To me the low hanging indicators overlap heavily with ICCLIM ... for which we already have the mock module which has a lot more name recognition.
Are their users that are that familiar with PCC's definitions and thrshold choices that we need to create a module specifically for this? Also a new 'PCC' module would bring yet another flavor to xclim (along with atmos and ICCLIM) and i think it might start becoming confusing
I think a dedicated agricultural module including the missing things like corn heat units etc etc would be more interesting
I have plans for this already. It needs a few more very specific indices.
I guess my thinking was to make it easy for the PCC to use xclim by clarifying the mapping between xclim's indicators and theirs. Agree this has a very limited use outside the PCC and we could provide them with the mock module offline.
Could we possibly have 'targeted' notebooks appearing in pavics jupyter instances? I don,t think they should necessarily be in the 'read the docs' for pavics-sdi but could be available in the tutorial notebooks for individual users on the jupyter hub.. not sure
Example : I am working on an notebook for climatedata.ca to show the various steps in the calculations (in reallity for D. Caron so he can reproduce the outputs via the analysis page) but this could be useful as a workflow example for our jupyter users
Something similar could be done here for PCC... i.e. the mapping of xclim calcs for the PCC calculations
Description
Indicators used by PCC. Should we plan their inclusion ?