search

OutCast3k / coinbin

Javascript Bitcoin Wallet. Supports Multisig, Stealth, HD, SegWit, Bech32, Time Locked Addresses, RBF and more!
https://coinb.in/
MIT License
909 stars 622 forks source link

Cannot broadcast multisig redeem tx #72

Open Jpja opened 7 years ago

Jpja commented 7 years ago

Error Error 16: mandatory-script-verify-flag-failed (Non-canonical DER signature)

when broadcasting although transaction verifies ok.

More details :

vroomDotClub commented 7 years ago

SAME EXACT PROBLEM for me and i see nobody responed since jan 4th OUCH! this sucks

dueringa commented 6 years ago

Having the same problem - with the dogecoin network. Created 3 addresses, created a multisig 3-of-3, created a transaction and signed with all 3 private keys. Verify transaction says everything is okay.

Transaction in question: 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

Transmitting with Dogecoin client says 16: mandatory-script-verify-flag-failed (Script evaluated without error but finished with a false/empty top stack element) (code -26)

Website says A valid signed transaction hexadecimal string is required. Please check if all inputs in the given transactions are still available to spend. See the "Is Tx Output Spent?" API call for reference.

EDIT looks like in my case, it was a too low fee?

AndreyViktor commented 6 years ago

i have a pretty similar problem, created a raw transaction out of the reedem script(arround 85bytes), signed it with one PK(arround 190 bytes), but when i try to sign using the sencond PK the transaction that is generated is exactly the same as the previous as if it hasnt been signed, 190 bytes...