OvercastNetwork / Rotations

Overcast Network's public server rotations
38 stars 43 forks source link

Remove or update Valley of the dead from Control #246

Closed cgode69 closed 9 years ago

cgode69 commented 10 years ago

I like playing this map, it's beautiful and I like the "gear system". Sadly, a lot people love spawncamp on this map and it's like that at each game (come play and you'll understand)

I think this map should be removed or update to prevent the spawncamp

DoomRobotBoy commented 10 years ago

I do agree that spawncamping is a problem on this map. After someone acquires the OP gear it's easy to farm the other team.

The map is, however, very great looking and the gameplay is unique as well.

:+1: for improving

Electroid commented 9 years ago

There are three exits to the spawn.. seems hard to cover them all. Especially seeing how the base is pretty big. Map has great ratings of 3.71.

cgode69 commented 9 years ago

@Electroid No, I already saw people spawncamping. If we were spawncamping, there are 3 exits :

I like this map, it's very great looking and the gear system is nice but the spawncamp is really annoying

Strangely, people who are spawncamping are really known as killfarmers

DoomRobotBoy commented 9 years ago

Isn't spawncamping/killing illegal on this map? Because I thought that when you had different tiers (ex.: leather - iron - diamond) of gear in 1 map, spawn camping/killing was not allowed. So if you just make it so that everyone will realize it's illegal, the camping/killing will stop.

If it ain't I get how the spawn camping is very annoying, because the ones doing that clearly have better armor, and it's exactly that OP armor that makes the farming so easy.

I like Valley of the Dead for it's beauty and different gear system from others, though it's kinda turning into Valley of the Killfarmed in most matches.

Seode commented 9 years ago

@DoomRobotBoy Spawncamping is not illegal because it's KotH. This map is really large and it takes ages to get places. I suggest adding more portals to get back to spawn. Because this map has a gear system, spawncamping/killing happens in almost every map. One player on one team can get all the good gear and start spawncamping the other team. The opposing team can't get better armor because they are continually dying while the team with the OP player can improve their items. Here's a good example of a regular match of VotD https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sN6JA9YEQuc

ghost commented 9 years ago

@Seode It is illegal, the only exceptions are TDM and Blitz:

Spawn camping rules do not apply on Team Deathmatch and Blitz maps.

Superjd10 commented 9 years ago

@firstvirus92 AFAIK KotH is a TDM variant.

But I agree, this map is first to gear (spawn camp or killing enemies in coal recently spawned) = Win.

I've never seen a team holding a control point, just kill farming near enemy spawn.

Last time I played this map it was from 16v16 to 18v8 - 16v6.

ghost commented 9 years ago

REMOVE IT. It's very easy to kill farm (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sN6JA9YEQuc). Players that join in even two minutes after the start are at a major loss in terms of resources. Also, the points take way too long to capture, I rarely see people even try and go for them.

Electroid commented 9 years ago

You only get points from hills.. so killing the enemy will not benefit your score. If they are winning, it's purely from hills captured. If a team is able to overpower the other, why stop them?

HIVERaven commented 9 years ago

@electroidfilms

It turns into the better geared players killfarming and holding back the entire enemy team as their teammates get points. The gear snowballs too fast so that they can't be taken down.

DoomRobotBoy commented 9 years ago

When I played it a couple of times, we lost because we were to busy farming and getting OP gear :(

Basically we just forgot to get the points.

CoWinkKeyDinkInc commented 9 years ago

Maybe remove the <king/> tag?

ghost commented 9 years ago

Electroid have you even played this map? You can't stop an enemy team once they are fed with diamond armor and speed potions...

Strangeys commented 9 years ago

Removed.