OxygenCobalt
commented
1 year ago This is not under my control, and is actually from the media database automatically assigning the folder name to music. I also can't do my own filtering, as that will lead to collisions. For example, if an album has the name "0", is it because it's from audio files in /storage/emulated/0, or is it because the songs are from Low Roar's Album "0"?
322 should allow me to turn this behavior into a toggle. However, I'm not sure how to handle the fallback album case. Either:
- All songs without an album name are grouped into "Unknown Album" instances. This is easy to do.
- All songs without an album name just don't have an album at all. This is a thing I can do, but it also breaks one of the core invariants of Auxio's music model and requires a bunch more work.
occasionallyword
Description
I would like for Auxio to not automatically assign an Album to songs when no album is given in the metadata. I would like a setting for this behavior, instead of assuming it intentionally.
Currently, some of my library has Title and Artist metadata, but lacks Album metadata. Auxio will automatically display the Album as the name of the folder which my music is stored in on the, "Now Playing" screen. I understand that some people store music and separate albums by folders, but this functionality should probably be a setting inside of Auxio.
Problem solved
No response
Other implementations
In my experience, other players will either provide a setting for this behavior instead of assuming it, or will only display Album data when present within the tags of the individual song.
Benefit
This will benefit everyone's usage of Auxio by not providing an incorrect tag when no tag is present in the file. A setting to determine this behavior makes logical sense, and would satisfy the needs of people who group things by folders/directories as well as by tags themselves.
Duplicates