Open jrfnl opened 11 months ago
0: no errors found
1: errors found
2: fixable errors found
3: processing error
It does not look like all situations are mutually exclusive. For instance, it's possible to have fixable and unfixable errors found during the same run. This should IMO be encoded as 1+2=3. If a processing error happens, 4 should be added, and each new situation should be associated with a power of 2, so that it's possible to tell more about what happened from the exit code alone.
@greg0ire I'm sure Greg had some idea in mind on where he wanted to go with this when he created the issue, but the above is all the info which is available.
Personally, I would like errors and warnings to have separate exit codes, so that a coding standards error returns 1, whereas warnings with no errors returns 2 or something similar. Otherwise you have to grep the output to determine what type of error it is.
This would be helpful for using PHPCS in GitLab pipelines, because exit code can be used to determine whether a pipeline is allowed to fail. GitLab allows pipelines to specify essentially a "pass with warning" state, and the pipeline stage shows as yellow (warning) instead of green (success) or red (error). I'd like an easy way to determine that from the exit code, such as 0 (success), 1 (error), 2 (warnings, no errors).
I'd love for PHPCBF to return exit code 0
when fixable issues are found and fixed and there are no unfixable issues found.
composer coding-standards:fix
> phpcbf
F... 4 / 4 (100%)
PHPCBF RESULT SUMMARY
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FILE FIXED REMAINING
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
/Users/User/Desktop/my-org/my-repo/src/php/MyClass.php 1 0
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A TOTAL OF 1 ERROR WERE FIXED IN 1 FILE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Time: 128ms; Memory: 6MB
Script phpcbf handling the coding-standards:fix event returned with error code 1
The above example shows 1 error found and fixed. So the outcome is a success; yet it exits 1
as though it failed.
Repost from https://github.com/squizlabs/PHP_CodeSniffer/issues/2898 by @gsherwood:
Additional info posted by @jrfnl:
And some related closed issues:
And the following open PR is also related:
Related remark posted by @nelson6e65:
Question by @dfelton:
Reply by @jrfnl: