PROconsortium / PRoteinOntology

Other
12 stars 3 forks source link

PR:000050494 #318

Closed ValWood closed 5 months ago

ValWood commented 5 months ago
fix at PRO

Hi @nataled , could the text here be changed slightly to

A DNA-directed RNA polymerase II subunit rpb1 (Schizosaccharomyces pombe) that has been phosphorylated at ~either~ the second, fifth, ~or~ and seventh positions of one or more of the C-terminal heptad repeats (YSPTSPS). [PMID:28367989, PRO:DAN, PomBase:VW]

Here, the CTD code is dependent on the 3 modifications occurring together (although this may not always be present on every repeat)

nataled commented 5 months ago

Hi Val, In my interim release version of PRO, the sentence also includes the fourth position: "A DNA-directed RNA polymerase II subunit rpb1 (Schizosaccharomyces pombe) that has been phosphorylated at either the second, fourth, fifth, and/or seventh positions of one or more of the C-terminal heptad repeats (YSPTSPS)." I assume there had to have been a request for that change previously. Should I merge the two changes, or remove the fourth position...?

ValWood commented 5 months ago

Actually, the paper I used for the initial one it is an 'or', although I suspect the 'activated' form is both. Let's leave this for now because the annotation as it is is correct, and I know new papers are in the pipeline so I can refine with the correct combinations to reflect the active code from those.

nataled commented 5 months ago

Ha! The same outcome as the last ticket about this term :)

nataled commented 5 months ago

There's no reason multiple versions can't exist, like one with the 'or' and one without.

ValWood commented 5 months ago

I think that might need to happen. I'm trying to piece together from multiple papers, but it isn't easy to interpret the experiments which depend on them mutating the residues in every repeat/ and or having very precise antibodies. I also know new papers are coming along, and that is a better point to review the existing annotation (things might change again, or become more precise)