search

PaperMC / Velocity

The modern, next-generation Minecraft server proxy.
https://papermc.io/software/velocity
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.74k stars 605 forks source link

Switching logging frameworks #1397

Closed SergioK29 closed 1 month ago

SergioK29 commented 1 month ago

Requested Feature

Log4j is very inefficient, bloated and has had security issues in the past. For velocity's use case (which is very simple, just writing lines to log file and zipping old logs), something simpler such as tinylog or more modern such as logback would be an improvement.

Why is this needed?

Log4j is bloated, has security issues, and has bad performance

Alternative Solutions

🤷

Additional Information

No response

electronicboy commented 1 month ago

I'm not sure that l4j is really causing enough issues for us to deal with diverging away from the rest of the ecosystem, and if we did, it would be a long ways away

SergioK29 commented 1 month ago

I'm not sure that l4j is really causing enough issues for us to deal with diverging away from the rest of the ecosystem, and if we did, it would be a long ways away

If I made a single class minimal logger that writes lines to a file and zips old ones, would velocity implement it? is there some kind of fancy other functionality that velocity uses loggers for or anything?

electronicboy commented 1 month ago

No, because people rely on L4J, and so we can't just break it without a strong reason to do so at an appropriate time to do so

electronicboy commented 1 month ago

Our terminal itself is also a Log4J appender; I've never really seen any issues with Log4J other than it having a metric ton of functionality which doesn't get enabled, and the fact that appenders are blocking by default, but, that is easy to mitigate once I can/do get around to it

We would need a really strong reason to migrate away from one of the most popular logging frameworks in use within the wider java ecosystem, not only pretty much the defacto option within our space, over fairly abstract complaints about the framework.

If there is an issue that you've actually seen with Log4J, i'd be interested to hear about it, but, as it stands, it would take something pretty large for me to consider migrating away from this, and is definitely not something we can just do on a whim with all of the ecosystem generally being tied to this.