search

Particular / ServiceInsight

Advanced debugging for NServiceBus
http://particular.net/serviceinsight
Other
16 stars 32 forks source link

"Jump to page" in message browsing #372

Closed synhershko closed 3 years ago

synhershko commented 10 years ago

At the moment, ServiceInsight, allows you to page the messages in this fashion: image

Have an option that will allow the user to jump directly to a specified page as opposed to clicking on next button many times.

johnsimons commented 10 years ago

funny this UI remind me of the 80s!

synhershko commented 10 years ago

John it's not nice to laugh at front-end developers :)

johnsimons commented 10 years ago

In all seriousness, there are better ways to page through list now a days. Things like virtual list are in my opinion a better fit for rich UIs like these.

That said, it is sad that w

johnsimons commented 10 years ago

That said, it is sad that we have to page through results at all. IMO a good searching bar should be the way to go.

johnsimons commented 10 years ago

@synhershko why do u want a browsing capability?

synhershko commented 10 years ago

Virtual lists were here in the 90's as well. It's just a cheat, not a real solution.

IMO paging with page numbers is the way to go here, especially considering deep paging with RavenDB is slooooow.

And yes search needs to be improved. /cc @dannycohen

johnsimons commented 10 years ago

@synhershko what are you working on?

distantcam commented 10 years ago

Assigned to @synhershko

dannycohen commented 10 years ago

FYI - Advanced Search requirements: https://github.com/Particular/Requirements/issues/4#issuecomment-34956800

// CC @synhershko , @johnsimons

synhershko commented 10 years ago

Removed my assignment as this is purely a UI issue, and I probably won't handle it well. While I'm resuming work on advanced search requirements, this still needs to be addressed IMO.

indualagarsamy commented 10 years ago

@synhershko - My vote is to remove the paging and the Jump to and move towards how SP handles failed messages, endless scroll, like facebook, like twitter and focus efforts on building a much sturdier, more usable advanced search option that will bring up a subset of the messages the user is looking for much easier. I'd like to close this issue. cc / @dannycohen - thoughts?

synhershko commented 10 years ago

I'm against, as scrolling in RavenDB is very costly. You want this to be explicitly requesed, and jump-to-page in itself can come in very handy.

indualagarsamy commented 10 years ago

@synhershko - ok, forget about the endless scroll. Just display, Showing top <x> results. To narrow down, use advanced search and be done with it. Jump to is not a user friendly option for the user. A working advanced search is.

synhershko commented 10 years ago

Ok, we should revisit this only once Advanced Search is implemented.

danielHalan commented 9 years ago

+1 for this until Advance Search is implemented, as paging thru 100's of pages is quite a pain.

danielHalan commented 9 years ago

Any progress on this?

johnsimons commented 9 years ago

@danielHalan not yet

mauroservienti commented 3 years ago

Closed in favor of https://github.com/Particular/ServiceInsight/issues/958