Mana Reflection doesn't double mana produced by mana abilities that provide mana in any combination of colors

PennyDreadfulMTG / modo-bugs

Issue Tracker for Magic Online bugs

6 stars 1 forks source link

Mana Reflection doesn't double mana produced by mana abilities that provide mana in any combination of colors #346

Open stash86 opened 6 years ago

stash86 commented 6 years ago

What is the expected behaviour of the card?

Mana produced by Selvala, Heart of the Wilds and others would be doubled by Mana Reflection's ability

What is the actual behaviour of the card?

Mana Refection doesn't doubling the mana produced by Selvala, Heart of the Wilds or the rest of the affected cards if they can add combination of colors to the mana pool. Reported by a reddit user here

Screenshot Currently Unconfirmed.

Please provide a list of affected cards Affects: [Mana Reflection].

See Also: [Selvala, Heart of the Wilds], [Axebane Guardian] [Altar of the Lost] [Terrarion] [Cascading Cataracts] [Crucible of the Spirit Dragon] [Prismatic Geoscope] [Shaman of Forgotten Ways] [Smokebraider]

Card Images

Rowsol commented 6 years ago

2018-04-06_154740

Before reflection I add 2 mana with her. After reflection, I still adds 2 (the other 1 is from tapping the forest).

stash86 commented 6 years ago

@rowsol Can you try with a gaea’s anthem in the battlefield? I want to know what will be the behavior. Trying to get better info of the bug. Thanks

Rowsol commented 6 years ago

2018-04-06_181428 I tapped the forest for 2 green, used her to add 1 of each black and red. No mana added by reflection.

2018-04-06_181523 Again, forest adds 2 green, use one for activation and add 8 due to 8/8. Reflection does nothing.

It simply doesn't do anything no matter how much mana you are adding. I'll note that my previous comment was suspicious because I noted it added a mana when it didn't, the extra simply came from tapping the forest with reflection in play.

stash86 commented 6 years ago

I added all 9 affected cards in the Affected Cards list together with Mana Reflection. Fell free to remove those 9 cards if it's not necessary to have them in the list.

silasary commented 6 years ago

The other cards should not have been in the Affected Cards line.

The warning was popping up every time somebody played a Terrarion.

stash86 commented 6 years ago

Still bugged

PennyDreadfulBot commented 5 years ago

Still bugged according to Fenume in match 218894062.

stash86 commented 4 years ago

Still bugged

PennyDreadfulBot commented 4 years ago

Still bugged according to stevendiaz in match 234352145.

PennyDreadfulBot commented 3 years ago

Still bugged according to datrobino in match 243661527.