Pfern / OSODOS

Open Science, Open Data, Open Source
http://osodos.org
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
26 stars 4 forks source link

Containerisation is imho a bit misrepresented #28

Open yarikoptic opened 5 years ago

yarikoptic commented 5 years ago

While working out https://github.com/Pfern/OSODOS/pull/27 and reading the opening of that paragraph

**containerisation** - a more lightweight solution for bundling tools that are
otherwise difficult to install is offered by "containerisation"

Although it is true, it is just a single use case, and may be not even that common or prominent reason in at least scientific computing. I have some experience (a Debian developer) with managing software dependencies, and overall systems administration etc., so I have no difficulty to install tools (as many others who use some good Linux distribution which comes with many packages available already). I do love containers for a variety of other reasons though

Virtualization is unnecessarily too heavy for any of those use cases, and thus in my world its use is greatly diminished.

So I think that this paragraph should be reword a little to reflect advantages of containers better.

rvosa commented 5 years ago

I think that is a pretty good point, I agree that the section could probably be updated to reflect that. We'll keep this in the tracker for if/when we move to create a new 'edition'. Thanks!

rvosa commented 5 years ago

I have only just got around to merging in the pull requests you have so kindly provided. For now I'd like to keep this issue open if only for the purpose of reminding us to credit you as a contributor to this.

yarikoptic commented 5 years ago

Thanks! My contribution was very minor so you could close for this one, may be I will contribute more on the future and then will demand to be credited ;-)