Closed purelind closed 1 week ago
I Skip it since the diff size(106108 bytes > 80000 bytes) is too large
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4 |
๐งช Relevant tests | Yes |
๐ Security concerns | No |
โก Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The PR introduces multiple Jenkins pipeline configurations and scripts for various integration tests. It is crucial to ensure that these scripts handle error cases gracefully and clean up resources even when tests fail. This is particularly important in environments like Kubernetes where resources can be limited and expensive. |
Performance Concern: The configurations specify resource limits and requests for containers in Kubernetes. It's important to validate that these settings are appropriate for the expected workload. Over-provisioning can lead to wasted resources, while under-provisioning can cause poor performance and timeouts. | |
Hardcoded Values: There are several hardcoded values within the scripts (e.g., memory and CPU limits, specific version tags for Docker images). These should ideally be parameterized to make the pipelines more flexible and easier to update. |
PR-Agent was enabled for this repository. To continue using it, please link your git user with your CodiumAI identity here.
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Ensure that logs are always collected after the tests, even if they are successful___ **Add apost block to the stage('Tests') section to ensure that logs are always collected, even if the tests are successful.** [pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.groovy [123-163]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-f2a506647a81220597db1b49119559fb2b4a65d2466332659e9c92a451d792f1R123-R163) ```diff stage('Tests') { when { expression { !skipRemainingStages} } matrix { axes { axis { name 'TEST_GROUP' values 'G00', 'G01', 'G02', 'G03', 'G04', 'G05', 'G06', 'G07', 'G08', 'G09', 'G10', 'G11', 'G12', 'G13', 'G14', 'G15', 'G16', 'G17' } } agent{ kubernetes { namespace K8S_NAMESPACE yamlFile POD_TEMPLATE_FILE defaultContainer 'golang' } } stages { stage("Test") { options { timeout(time: 40, unit: 'MINUTES') } steps { dir('tiflow') { cache(path: "./", includes: '**/*', key: "ws/${BUILD_TAG}/tiflow-cdc") { sh label: "${TEST_GROUP}", script: """ rm -rf /tmp/tidb_cdc_test && mkdir -p /tmp/tidb_cdc_test chmod +x ./tests/integration_tests/run_group.sh ./tests/integration_tests/run_group.sh pulsar ${TEST_GROUP} """ } } } post { - failure { + always { sh label: "collect logs", script: """ ls /tmp/tidb_cdc_test/ tar -cvzf log-${TEST_GROUP}.tar.gz \$(find /tmp/tidb_cdc_test/ -type f -name "*.log") ls -alh log-${TEST_GROUP}.tar.gz """ archiveArtifacts artifacts: "log-${TEST_GROUP}.tar.gz", fingerprint: true } } } } } } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Modifying the `post` block to collect logs regardless of test success or failure is crucial for debugging and should be implemented to capture all possible outcomes. | 8 |
Prevent multiple instances of the job from running simultaneously___ **Add adisableConcurrentBuilds property to prevent multiple instances of the job from running simultaneously, which can help avoid potential conflicts and resource contention.** [jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy [15-36]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-ac26bcfd0e593c87a437582a49f0de2fa15ebce018650eb387278b60448511f2R15-R36) ```diff +disableConcurrentBuilds() definition { cpsScm { lightweight(true) scriptPath("pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy") scm { git{ remote { url('https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci.git') } branch('main') extensions { cloneOptions { depth(1) shallow(true) timeout(5) } } } } } } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding `disableConcurrentBuilds()` is crucial for avoiding conflicts and resource contention, making it a significant improvement in job configuration. | 8 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Consider adding a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Use a variable for the path to the
___
**To avoid potential issues with hardcoded paths, consider using a variable for the path to | 6 | |
Possible issue |
Add a catch block to handle exceptions during the
___
**To improve error handling, consider adding a catch block to handle exceptions that may | 8 |
Maintainability |
Extract repeated cache block into a reusable function to reduce code duplication___ **To improve readability and maintainability, consider extracting the repeated cache blockinto a reusable function. This will reduce code duplication and make future updates easier.** [pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.groovy [71-77]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-beed5a839362dc58691be662a4bdc0118cfacfff2121015157ff67c0a9854091R71-R77) ```diff -cache(path: "./", includes: '**/*', key: prow.getCacheKey('git', REFS), restoreKeys: prow.getRestoreKeys('git', REFS)) { - retry(2) { - script { - prow.checkoutRefs(REFS) +def cacheAndCheckout(path, includes, key, restoreKeys, refs) { + cache(path: path, includes: includes, key: key, restoreKeys: restoreKeys) { + retry(2) { + script { + prow.checkoutRefs(refs) + } } } } +cacheAndCheckout("./", '**/*', prow.getCacheKey('git', REFS), prow.getRestoreKeys('git', REFS), REFS) + ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion correctly identifies code duplication in caching logic and proposes a reusable function, improving maintainability. | 7 |
Extract the repeated Docker login command into a reusable function___ **To improve readability and maintainability, extract the repeated Docker login command intoa reusable function.** [pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_dm_integration_test.groovy [208]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-06c105db3145c66697deee88427d598bac8d0e5e8fbe29aaa3b747896a1dba0aR208-R208) ```diff -echo "$HARBOR_CRED_PSW" | docker login -u $HARBOR_CRED_USR --password-stdin hub.pingcap.net +def dockerLogin() { + sh """ + echo "$HARBOR_CRED_PSW" | docker login -u $HARBOR_CRED_USR --password-stdin hub.pingcap.net + """ +} +... +dockerLogin() ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Extracting the Docker login command into a reusable function improves maintainability and reduces code duplication, which is beneficial for long-term code management. | 6 | |
Enhancement |
Use a loop to define
___
**To enhance the readability and maintainability of the script, consider using a loop to | 7 |
Add a property to discard old builds based on the number of builds___ **Consider adding adiscardOldBuilds property to the logRotator block to ensure that old builds are properly discarded based on the number of builds as well as the number of days.** [jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy [3-5]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-ac26bcfd0e593c87a437582a49f0de2fa15ebce018650eb387278b60448511f2R3-R5) ```diff logRotator { daysToKeep(30) + numToKeep(10) } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding a `numToKeep` property to the `logRotator` block is a valid enhancement for better build management, though not critical. | 7 | |
Add a trigger to periodically poll the SCM for changes___ **Add apollSCM trigger to periodically check for changes in the repository, ensuring the job is triggered automatically when there are updates.** [jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy [12-14]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-ac26bcfd0e593c87a437582a49f0de2fa15ebce018650eb387278b60448511f2R12-R14) ```diff properties { githubProjectUrl("https://github.com/pingcap/tiflow") } +triggers { + pollSCM('H/15 * * * *') +} ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Adding a `pollSCM` trigger is a useful feature for automation, enhancing the job to automatically check for repository updates. | 6 | |
Robustness |
Add a property to retry the checkout operation in case of transient errors___ **Include acheckoutRetryCount property in the git block to specify the number of retry attempts for the checkout operation, improving robustness in case of transient errors.** [jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy [21-34]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3008/files#diff-ac26bcfd0e593c87a437582a49f0de2fa15ebce018650eb387278b60448511f2R21-R34) ```diff git{ remote { url('https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci.git') } branch('main') + checkoutRetryCount(3) extensions { cloneOptions { depth(1) shallow(true) timeout(5) } } } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Including a `checkoutRetryCount` in the `git` block improves robustness by handling transient errors during checkout, which is a practical enhancement. | 7 |
[APPROVALNOTIFIER] This PR is APPROVED
This pull-request has been approved by: wuhuizuo
The full list of commands accepted by this bot can be found here.
The pull request process is described here
Timeline:
2024-06-25 08:17:05.178926498 +0000 UTC m=+707551.664415332
: :ballot_box_with_check: agreed by wuhuizuo.
User description
tiflow split release 8.2 jobs
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
pingcap/tiflow
release 8.2.Changes walkthrough ๐
25 files
aa_folder.groovy
Create folder for `pingcap/tiflow` release 8.2 pipelines
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/aa_folder.groovy
pingcap/tiflow
release 8.2 pipelines.ghpr_verify.groovy
Define `ghpr_verify` pipeline job for release 8.2
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/ghpr_verify.groovy
ghpr_verify
.pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.groovy
Define `pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test` pipeline job for release 8.2
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test
.pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test.groovy
Define `pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test` pipeline job for release 8.2
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test
.pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.groovy
Define
pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test
pipeline job for release 8.2jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test
.pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy
Define
pull_cdc_integration_storage_test
pipeline job for release 8.2jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_storage_test
.pull_dm_compatibility_test.groovy
Define `pull_dm_compatibility_test` pipeline job for release 8.2
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_dm_compatibility_test.groovy
pull_dm_compatibility_test
.pull_dm_integration_test.groovy
Define `pull_dm_integration_test` pipeline job for release 8.2
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_dm_integration_test.groovy
pull_dm_integration_test
.pull_engine_integration_test.groovy
Define `pull_engine_integration_test` pipeline job for release 8.2
jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_engine_integration_test.groovy
pull_engine_integration_test
.ghpr_verify.groovy
Implement `ghpr_verify` pipeline script for release 8.2
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/ghpr_verify.groovy
ghpr_verify
pipeline script.pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.groovy
Implement
pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test
pipeline script for release8.2
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test
pipeline script.pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test.groovy
Implement
pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test
pipeline script for release8.2
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test
pipeline script.pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.groovy
Implement
pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test
pipeline script for release8.2
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test
pipeline script.pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy
Implement
pull_cdc_integration_storage_test
pipeline script forrelease 8.2
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.groovy
pull_cdc_integration_storage_test
pipeline script.pull_dm_compatibility_test.groovy
Implement
pull_dm_compatibility_test
pipeline script for release 8.2pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_dm_compatibility_test.groovy
pull_dm_compatibility_test
pipeline script.pull_dm_integration_test.groovy
Implement `pull_dm_integration_test` pipeline script for release 8.2
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_dm_integration_test.groovy
pull_dm_integration_test
pipeline script.pull_engine_integration_test.groovy
Implement
pull_engine_integration_test
pipeline script for release 8.2pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pull_engine_integration_test.groovy
pull_engine_integration_test
pipeline script.pod-ghpr_verify.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `ghpr_verify`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-ghpr_verify.yaml
ghpr_verify
.pod-pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test.yaml
pull_cdc_integration_kafka_test
.pod-pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test.yaml
pull_cdc_integration_mysql_test
.pod-pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test.yaml
pull_cdc_integration_pulsar_test
.pod-pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for
pull_cdc_integration_storage_test
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_cdc_integration_storage_test.yaml
pull_cdc_integration_storage_test
.pod-pull_dm_compatibility_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `pull_dm_compatibility_test`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_dm_compatibility_test.yaml
pull_dm_compatibility_test
.pod-pull_dm_integration_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `pull_dm_integration_test`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_dm_integration_test.yaml
pull_dm_integration_test
.pod-pull_engine_integration_test.yaml
Define Kubernetes pod template for `pull_engine_integration_test`
pipelines/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2/pod-pull_engine_integration_test.yaml
pull_engine_integration_test
.2 files
kustomization.yaml
Update kustomization to include release 8.2 presubmits
prow-jobs/kustomization.yaml - Added new entry for `release-8.2-presubmits.yaml`.
release-8.2-presubmits.yaml
Define presubmits for `pingcap/tiflow` release 8.2
prow-jobs/pingcap/tiflow/release-8.2-presubmits.yaml
pingcap/tiflow
release 8.2.