Closed wuhuizuo closed 1 week ago
I Skip it since the diff size(196601 bytes > 80000 bytes) is too large
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 5 |
๐งช Relevant tests | Yes |
๐ Security concerns | No |
โก Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The PR introduces a large number of Jenkins pipeline scripts and configurations for various integration, unit, and other types of tests. It is crucial to ensure that these scripts are thoroughly reviewed for syntax errors, logical errors, and potential inefficiencies. For example, the extensive use of shell scripts within the Jenkins pipeline code could be error-prone and hard to maintain. |
Performance Concerns: The extensive matrix configurations in the Jenkins pipeline might lead to a significant resource allocation and prolonged execution time. It's important to ensure that the resources are optimally used and the execution time is minimized. | |
Hardcoded Values: There are several hardcoded values within the scripts, such as namespace names, file paths, and environment variables. These should ideally be parameterized to make the pipelines more flexible and environment-agnostic. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Use
___
**Use | 9 |
Best practice |
Add a
___
**Consider adding a | 8 |
Add a
___
**Consider adding a | 8 | |
Add a
___
**Consider adding a | 8 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 6 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 6 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 6 | |
Possible issue |
Add a retry block around the artifact download commands to handle transient failures___ **Add aretry block around the sh command in the Prepare stage to handle transient failures when downloading artifacts.** [pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_check2.groovy [57-75]](https://github.com/PingCAP-QE/ci/pull/3011/files#diff-36b79bfdc97468ed652103e48f1c087f194942c33313b4f636ac598ef85c28feR57-R75) ```diff stage("Prepare") { steps { dir('tidb') { cache(path: "./bin", includes: '**/*', key: "binary/pingcap/tidb/tidb-server/rev-${REFS.base_sha}-${REFS.pulls[0].sha}") { sh label: 'tidb-server', script: 'ls bin/tidb-server || make server' } script { - component.fetchAndExtractArtifact(FILE_SERVER_URL, 'tikv', REFS.base_ref, REFS.pulls[0].title, 'centos7/tikv-server.tar.gz', 'bin', trunkBranch="master", artifactVerify=true) - component.fetchAndExtractArtifact(FILE_SERVER_URL, 'pd', REFS.base_ref, REFS.pulls[0].title, 'centos7/pd-server.tar.gz', 'bin', trunkBranch="master", artifactVerify=true) + retry(3) { + component.fetchAndExtractArtifact(FILE_SERVER_URL, 'tikv', REFS.base_ref, REFS.pulls[0].title, 'centos7/tikv-server.tar.gz', 'bin', trunkBranch="master", artifactVerify=true) + component.fetchAndExtractArtifact(FILE_SERVER_URL, 'pd', REFS.base_ref, REFS.pulls[0].title, 'centos7/pd-server.tar.gz', 'bin', trunkBranch="master", artifactVerify=true) + } } // cache it for other pods cache(path: "./", includes: '**/*', key: "ws/${BUILD_TAG}") { sh """ mv bin/tidb-server bin/integration_test_tidb-server touch rev-${REFS.pulls[0].sha} """ } } } } ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding a `retry` block around artifact download commands is a good practice to handle potential transient network or service issues, ensuring robustness in the pipeline. | 7 |
Add a retry block around the
___
**Add a | 7 | |
Add a timeout to the
___
**Consider adding a | 7 | |
Add a
___
**Add a | 6 | |
Enhancement |
Add a
___
**Add a | 7 |
I Skip it since the diff size(201812 bytes > 80000 bytes) is too large
I Skip it since the diff size(202027 bytes > 80000 bytes) is too large
[APPROVALNOTIFIER] This PR is APPROVED
This pull-request has been approved by: purelind
The full list of commands accepted by this bot can be found here.
The pull request process is described here
I Skip it since the diff size(198336 bytes > 80000 bytes) is too large
New changes are detected. LGTM label has been removed.
/hold
I Skip it since the diff size(202149 bytes > 80000 bytes) is too large
/unhold
User description
Signed-off-by: wuhuizuo wuhuizuo@126.com
PR Type
enhancement, tests
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
35 files
pull_sqllogic_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for SQL logic tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_sqllogic_test.groovy
settings.
pull_check2.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for additional checks
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_check2.groovy
combinations.
pull_integration_jdbc_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for JDBC integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_jdbc_test.groovy
stores.
pull_build.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for project build
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_build.groovy
pull_integration_common_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for common integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_common_test.groovy
pull_integration_ddl_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for DDL integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_ddl_test.groovy
pull_integration_mysql_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for MySQL integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_mysql_test.groovy
pull_integration_br_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for BR integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_br_test.groovy
pull_integration_lightning_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for Lightning integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_lightning_test.groovy
pull_integration_python_orm_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for Python ORM integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_python_orm_test.groovy
and stores.
pull_integration_nodejs_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for Node.js integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_nodejs_test.groovy
pull_mysql_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for MySQL tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_mysql_test.groovy
pull_unit_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for unit tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_unit_test.groovy
archiving.
pull_tiflash_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for TiFlash tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_tiflash_test.groovy
pull_common_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for common tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_common_test.groovy
commands.
pull_integration_copr_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for coprocessor integration tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_copr_test.groovy
pull_e2e_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for end-to-end tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_e2e_test.groovy
pull_mysql_client_test.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for MySQL client tests
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_mysql_client_test.groovy
pull_check.groovy
Add Jenkins pipeline for code checks
pipelines/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_check.groovy
archiving.
pull_build.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for build pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_build.groovy
pull_check2.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for additional checks pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_check2.groovy
pull_integration_python_orm_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for Python ORM integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_python_orm_test.groovy
pipeline.
pull_mysql_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for MySQL tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_mysql_test.groovy
pull_unit_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for unit tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_unit_test.groovy
pull_check.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for code checks pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_check.groovy
pull_e2e_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for end-to-end tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_e2e_test.groovy
pull_integration_copr_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for coprocessor integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_copr_test.groovy
pipeline.
pull_integration_ddl_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for DDL integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_ddl_test.groovy
pull_integration_jdbc_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for JDBC integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_jdbc_test.groovy
pipeline.
pull_integration_lightning_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for Lightning integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_lightning_test.groovy
pipeline.
pull_integration_nodejs_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for Node.js integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_nodejs_test.groovy
pipeline.
pull_tiflash_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for TiFlash tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_tiflash_test.groovy
pull_integration_br_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for BR integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_br_test.groovy
pull_integration_common_test.groovy
Add Jenkins job DSL for common integration tests pipeline
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/pull_integration_common_test.groovy
pipeline.
aa_folder.groovy
Add Jenkins folder configuration for release-8.2 pipelines
jobs/pingcap/tidb/release-8.2/aa_folder.groovy
pipelines.