PlayersCommittee / gemp-swccg-public

Online Play system for SWCCG
https://gemp.starwarsccg.org/
MIT License
27 stars 29 forks source link

Transfering Devices - Present with vs Present at the site #728

Open hayesbug opened 9 months ago

hayesbug commented 9 months ago

Rules state:

Devices - Deploy, Carrying, And Transferring See Weapons - Deploying And Carrying; Weapons - Transferring.

Weapons - Transferring During your deploy phase, you may transfer your weapon (or device) from one of your characters, vehicles, or starships to another such card present with the targeted character, vehicle, or starship on which the weapon is currently deployed by using Force equal to the deploy cost of the weapon (or device) and obeying all relevant deployment restrictions.

In other words - two characters inside a vehicle or ship should be able to transfer a device from one to the other. Gemp is incorrectly using "present at the site" instead of "present with."

In the replay, we see the device cannot transfer between two characters inside a vehicle. It does, however, permit the transfer from inside the vehicle to the character outside the vehicle (not the other way around). This is not in accordance w/ the rules.

https://gemp.starwarsccg.org/gemp-swccg/game.html?replayId=Hayes$ymejxva7o3fxarek

(feel free to ignore our testing of immunity of an unpiloted/landed starship and jedi lev redraw stuff)