search

PoomSmart / Return-YouTube-Dislikes

Bring Back Dislikes On YouTube iOS.
https://chariz.com/get/return-youtube-dislike
GNU General Public License v3.0
48 stars 22 forks source link

Broken in YouTube Shorts Tab #70

Closed Weather-OS closed 3 months ago

Weather-OS commented 3 months ago

The dislike and like count show the count of the previous short instead of the current short.

PoomSmart commented 3 months ago

Should be fixed in v1.11.18

Weather-OS commented 3 months ago

Still broken 2A7EF02A-6852-46D9-B95D-FEA4632F9A18

PoomSmart commented 3 months ago

How do you know it's really from the previous short?

Weather-OS commented 3 months ago

In that instance, the previous short had like 253 likes or something so it would make sense for it to have 3 dislikes.

PoomSmart commented 2 months ago

@Weather-OS Can you give me the link to that Short?

PoomSmart commented 2 months ago

By the way, it makes total sense for the like/dislike ratio to be like that because not everyone has Return YouTube Dislike (whether it's a browser extension, hacked app or this tweak) installed. If the video author doesn't explicitly contribute the actual vote data to RYD server, then the dislike number you see is the total number of dislikes from RYD users.

For example, this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oE8hAQie8fw

Like: 56K Dislike: 394

For a MV such as this the number of dislikes should be in thousands if not more.

Weather-OS commented 2 months ago

By the way, it makes total sense for the like/dislike ratio to be like that because not everyone has Return YouTube Dislike (whether it's a browser extension, hacked app or this tweak) installed. If the video author doesn't explicitly contribute the actual vote data to RYD server, then the dislike number you see is the total number of dislikes from RYD users.

For example, this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oE8hAQie8fw

Like: 56K Dislike: 394

For a MV such as this the number of dislikes should be in thousands if not more.

I’m just trying this out again and yes I can confirm it is definitely showing the dislike count of the previous short. I found a short with 3.1 Million likes and only 6 dislikes. Then the short under it had 52 likes and 91 thousand dislikes.

Weather-OS commented 2 months ago

36AEB725-DF6E-4B33-A797-30679130D2E4

PoomSmart commented 2 months ago

Sorry but I can't reproduce that issue. Besides the reason I wrote above that would already refute your confirmation, I verified that the API returns the correct vote data and what current short is displayed using the video ID. If you think this issue is legitimate, open a new issue stating the exact shorts that you found the vote data to be shifting.