Portree-Kid / flightgear-airports

GNU General Public License v3.0
6 stars 1 forks source link

Attempted upload produces error: Unknown Radius in parking #47

Closed Honu4 closed 4 years ago

Honu4 commented 4 years ago

In-app check is fine. When attempting to upload airport an error is produced and checklist is populated with "Unkown Radius" errors at parking positions and upload fails. MacOS

Screen Shot 2020-07-09 at 3 46 26 PM
BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago

Click on the target icon next to unknown radius message and paste here a screenshot of the parkpos screen (if the radius looks ok)

Honu4 commented 4 years ago

3 random spots. Not sure what's up with the taxiline node.

Screen Shot 2020-07-10 at 11 37 06 PM Screen Shot 2020-07-10 at 11 37 46 PM Screen Shot 2020-07-10 at 11 38 43 PM
BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago

S1 : No idea why a parkpos error is returned for a node > Keith

S2 : Aircrafts cannot pivot on their parkpos. Looks like you are entering parking through the nose ?

Segments in and out of parkpos must have the same heading than parkpos itself

See screenshot: Left hand side, if you leave the parkpos rolling forward, Right hand side if you leave the parkpos pushing back (using the same route you used to get in)

image

BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago

@Portree-Kid

Error shown on screenshot 3 by Honu4, are you testing segment heading vs parkpos heading ? Is this the error in your view? If yes, messaging should be "Parkpos route access not aligned"

Secreenshot 1 : totally confused :-)

Honu4 commented 4 years ago

@BecOzIcan How are you getting the directional indicators on the taxilines? This is how they are rendering for me, MacOS. Direction supposedly from L-R

Screen Shot 2020-07-11 at 10 08 37 AM
BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago

Not sure, they appear automatically for me. maybe be a missing font/icon on the mac version

BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago

Confirming the error/bug.

v0.019 Click Check Icon in RHS Panel (between Save and Bi Directional Icons) Get "Results" panel : Shows all ticked/OK produces full validation image

SAVE (RHS Panel Icon) UPLOAD (RHS Panel Icon Above Export)

Returns 46 Unknown (and Immaterial) Radius Errors

image

Portree-Kid commented 4 years ago

Reason is, that the boxes are not visible. I see two ways forward.

  1. Boxes are visible in non edit mode.
  2. Boxes are generated non visible.

I'm for 1.

BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago

Sorry I don't understand the comment. What 'Boxes' are you referring to ? I should have kept both issues (taxiway marking and validation discrepancies) separate

GOT IT! (The Parking Spaces) : Yes. Should be the single representation of ParkPos in both Edit and non Edit mode. Circle ParkPos should no longer be exposed to end user even if still exist in check code for pre selection of overlaps)

Portree-Kid commented 4 years ago

They are connected. In edit view only parkings with known radii have the box. The others have a circle. The check can only do the exact overlap check with the parking box.

BecOzIcan commented 4 years ago
  1. Happy with your recommendation of Boxes shown in Non Edit mode where radii is standard (preferably replace the circle)
  2. Still an issues with discrepancies in checks originally reported by Honu: there is no way I have 46 overlapping parkpos at VVNB, whatever the shape (total umber of parkpos is 46)

image

image

wkitty42 commented 4 years ago

How are you getting the directional indicators on the taxilines?

i have the same question... mine are also red boxes on linux using the appimage... will create a new issue for that to separate it out... done... issue #56

Portree-Kid commented 4 years ago

Fixed in 0.0.20