search

PrismarineJS / minecraft-data

Language independent module providing minecraft data for minecraft clients, servers and libraries.
https://prismarinejs.github.io/minecraft-data
651 stars 222 forks source link

Identifcation of experimental features/items? #847

Open Nuri0 opened 7 months ago

Nuri0 commented 7 months ago

The version 1.20.3 contained some items that are not part of the main game, but are only available with the "Update 1.21" switch / data-pack (e.g. "crafter" or "trial_key").

https://github.com/PrismarineJS/minecraft-data/blob/master/data/pc/1.20.3/items.json

These items are listed as if they were part of the main game or is there some indication, which marks these items as "experimental" or "preview" that I am missing?

extremeheat commented 7 months ago

No, there's no classification for that currently, minecraft-data includes every block and item a client/server supports for any specific version, as it's obtained with a generator script running on Minecraft. But PRs are open if you want to add the labels, what is your use case?

Nuri0 commented 7 months ago

I wanted to generate kind of a history of minecraft items. For this I planned to group items by the version they were added in - simply by looking at diff of consecutive versions. Technically this still works for the mentioned items/blocks as they were added in 1.20.3 (23w42a) even if they are "hidden" behind the flag.

rom1504 commented 7 months ago

I think @wgaylord was looking into this recently

wgaylord commented 7 months ago

I will say they WERE added as they always take up space in the block registry even with the flag off, you just can't access them with it off. (Which is why they are included.) Annoyingly there is no good way to automatically grab what feature blocks or items are part of :(