Storage-time not fully redeeming to ~50GBs-months on a new voucher

[elric-wamugu]

Summary

Each voucher should give a user ~50GBs-months of storage-time once redeemed. However, in some instances, the storage-time does not fully update its balance till 50GBs-months on the GUI client (Gridsync).

Restarting the GUI client sometimes triggers the storage-time update which then continues to update the available storage-time till the expected ~50GBs-months that each redeemable voucher grants.

Screencast showing storage-time not fully redeeming to ~50GB-months on a new voucher: Storage-time not fully redeeming.webm

Debug log: Gridsync debug information - Storage-time not fully redeeming.txt

Screenshot showing storage-time updating after the GUI client relaunch:

However, relaunching the GUI client does not always trigger the storage-time balance to update: Screencast from 09-12-2022 02:35:52 PM.webm

Test Environment

Hardware info: VirtualBox Version 6.1.34 (Qt5.15.3) OS Version: MacOS 12.5 & 11.6.8

[crwood]

Thanks for filing this, @elric-wamugu. The relevant error here appears to be this one (written to Tahoe-LAFS' stdout):

>>> 2022-09-12T06:43:56-0700 [_zkapauthorizer.controller.PaymentController#critical] Redeeming random tokens for a voucher (b'Xt-8_DIczIyXWuUT3wn6d9Sm21GBgn3q7KwsKteZx6MD') encountered error.
>>>     Traceback (most recent call last):
>>>       File "twisted/internet/defer.py", line 1750, in gotResult
>>>       File "twisted/internet/defer.py", line 1737, in _inlineCallbacks
>>>       File "twisted/internet/defer.py", line 661, in callback
>>>       File "twisted/internet/defer.py", line 763, in _startRunCallbacks
>>>     --- <exception caught here> ---
>>>       File "twisted/internet/defer.py", line 857, in _runCallbacks
>>>       File "_zkapauthorizer/controller.py", line 933, in _redeem_success
>>>       File "_zkapauthorizer/model.py", line 223, in with_cursor
>>>       File "_zkapauthorizer/model.py", line 574, in insert_unblinded_tokens_for_voucher
>>>       File "_zkapauthorizer/model.py", line 581, in _delete_corresponding_tokens
>>>       File "_zkapauthorizer/replicate.py", line 521, in execute
>>>     sqlite3.DatabaseError: database disk image is malformed
>>> 2022-09-12T06:43:56-0700 [_zkapauthorizer.controller.PaymentController#info] Temporarily suspending redemption of b'Xt-8_DIczIyXWuUT3wn6d9Sm21GBgn3q7KwsKteZx6MD' after non-success result.

Did you happen to be able to reproduce this under any other environment(s)?

[exarkun]

Is this environment virtualized? If so, what VM manager is being used? And, is the ZKAPAuthorizer database on a shared filesystem of some sort (shared between the VM and the host, in particular - but any kind of sharing is interesting)?

[elric-wamugu]

@exarkun I have updated the issue description to include the testing environment.

The VM has its own dynamic virtual disk image (VDI) that is exclusive to that VM only so not shared between other file systems

[exarkun]

@meejah @crwood and I tried and failed to reproduce on macOS in VirtualBox. We don't really have a plausible theory for what's going on here except for the runtime environment corrupting the data between the virtual disk and the SQLite3 library.

One thing we noted is that database read operations immediately following the failed write operation succeeded. Either those operations don't stumble over the problem area the write encounters (I don't know if this is plausible given SQLite3's mode of operation) or the corruption is transient (which would lend credence to the "flaky VM" explanation, I think).

It would be great to be able to look at the database file immediately after this happens, or even better to be able to look at the whole VM image.

@elric-wamugu Can you keep an eye out for this happening again and if it does, shut down GridSync and share both the debug logs and the whole Tahoe-LAFS client node directory?