search

Pro / dkim-exchange

DKIM Signing Agent for Microsoft Exchange Server
Other
408 stars 143 forks source link

Multi-domain aliases not signing correctly #378

Open barkerest opened 1 year ago

barkerest commented 1 year ago

Versions

Description

When sending as an alias on a multi-domain setup, the signature is applied from the "home" domain instead of the alias domain.

Steps to Reproduce

  1. Have multiple domains configured (eg - alpha.com, bravo.com).
  2. Have a user with multiple aliases spread across the domains (eg - jdoe@alpha.com, jdoe@bravo.com).
  3. Have the user send a message using one of their aliases (this can be done via an SMTP session, an addon, etc).

Expected behavior: The message should be signed using the keys for the sender domain. If the user sent their message from jdoe@bravo.com, the message should be signed using the keys from bravo.com.

Actual behavior: The message is signed using the keys from the user's primary email address. If the user sent their message from jdoe@bravo.com, the message is being signed using the keys from alpha.com instead.

Deckard99 commented 1 year ago

I can confirm this problem. The tansport agent seems to use RFC5321.MailFrom (envelope) as signing domain instead of RFC5322.From. As nobody seems to care for this tool anymore in regards of development, I guess this will probably stay this way.