search

Project-OSRM / osrm-backend

Open Source Routing Machine - C++ backend
http://map.project-osrm.org
BSD 2-Clause "Simplified" License
6.39k stars 3.39k forks source link

Car route is drived through highway=footway #669

Closed DinamikGitHub closed 11 years ago

DinamikGitHub commented 11 years ago

[Bug Report]

osrm01 http://osrm.at/4gU

DennisOSRM commented 11 years ago

Without looking at the data: check the access tags.

DinamikGitHub commented 11 years ago

There is tag access=yes on highway=footway, but I don't think, that recognizing tag access=yes as a value with meaning "everyone can enter here even by car" is correct. highway=footway + access=yes means, that this footway is open for pedestrians. access=yes is identical to absense of tag access.

In any way choosing highway=footway instead of highway=tertiary is strange.

DennisOSRM commented 11 years ago

I saw you edited the OSM wiki to reflect this view. This is unfortunate and wrong. OSRM behavior is going to stick with the previous explanation.

Use the {{Key|access}} key to describe a general access restriction that applies to all transport modes

emiltin commented 11 years ago

@DinamikGitHub your intepretation of the access tag seems to be incorrect. i suggest you revert your changes to the wiki (Dennis reverted them for a reason) and discuss it on the mailing lists if you wish.