search

ProjectOpenSea / operator-filter-registry

MIT License
312 stars 93 forks source link

X2Y2 ENFORCEMENT BROKEN #83

Open DaWe35 opened 1 year ago

DaWe35 commented 1 year ago

You forced us to implement this last minute, and yet people can buy our NFTs with 0% fees on X2Y2.

We almost rescheduled the mint, because without [operator-filter-registry](https://github.com/ProjectOpenSea/operator-filter-registry), OpenSea won't enforce creator fees after January 2. So we were kinda forced to implement this, otherwise no one will pay fees.

Then as it turned out, it meant nothing, people can still buy/sell on X2Y2 with 0% creator fees. When I think it can't be worse, OpenSea proves there is always worse, and you charge you a ridiculous 2.5% fee for providing this unacceptable infrastructure. And if I want access to the API, fill a fckn google form and pray...

cagataygulten commented 1 year ago

Hey, What if you claim that collection on X2Y2 too and put a royalty fee?

DaWe35 commented 1 year ago

@cagataygulten then it works. My problem is that this repo give the false intention of forcing creator fees, while in reality you need to do the setup on other exchanges too. What's the point of storing the creator fee on-chain then?

cagataygulten commented 1 year ago

Yeah that is true, This package has no effects to enforce creator fee on-chain and you need to set on each marketplace seperately. As I understand, this package only filters marketplaces you can not set a creator fee. Here is the list of these: https://github.com/ProjectOpenSea/operator-filter-registry#filtered-addresses.

So you will have a enforced creator fee if you set it on all other marketplaces. It is still up to you.

DaWe35 commented 1 year ago

@cagataygulten I can set the fee on LooksRare, then why it is included? Also, why don't they write about that? If this repo is called as something what enforces fees, I'd expect to do that.