Jupyter book build issue - causing nightly build to fail

[rmshkv]

In the nightly build in this repo as well as other cookbooks, the Jupyter Book build step is failing with an error coming from Sphinx (full error here):

AttributeError: module 'docutils.nodes' has no attribute 'meta'

[brian-rose]

Thanks for the report @rmshkv, I noticed this too.

I'm not sure if this is related to issues with our Sphinx theme ( https://github.com/ProjectPythia/sphinx-pythia-theme/issues/39). @erogluorhan has been working on getting the theme up to date (https://github.com/ProjectPythia/sphinx-pythia-theme/pull/58).

[ktyle]

i'll take a look ASAP

[ktyle]

Looks like that when pip is installing our creaky old sphinx-pythia-theme, it is now updating the various sphinxcontrib libraries that are pinned in the conda environment from ProjectPythia/cookbook-actions#92 . Wonder if there is a way to pin libraries in pip as well?

[brian-rose]

Looks like that when pip is installing our creaky old sphinx-pythia-theme, it is now updating the various sphinxcontrib libraries that are pinned in the conda environment from ProjectPythia/cookbook-actions#92 . Wonder if there is a way to pin libraries in pip as well?

I'm not pip expert, but I think that is usually done in the requirements.txt file.

This is an unforunately legacy of the fact that the conda-forge recipe for our sphinx theme has been broken for years.

[brian-rose]

It's becoming more and more clear to me that we need to find a way to separate the environment description for the book build from the environment description for the notebook execution.

The first is generic and should be identical for every cookbook. It should be contained within a "Cookbook Infrastructure" package that can be maintained and versioned independently of the content of each Cookbook.

Whatever temporary fix we come up with here (possibly like https://github.com/ProjectPythia/ERA5_interactive-cookbook/pull/9) is going to need to be propagated across every existing Cookbook repo -- and then removed again once the upstream dependency issues get sorted out.

Related to #118 and https://github.com/ProjectPythia/cookbook-gallery/issues/86

[ktyle]

Assuming we can deploy a new sphinx-pythia-theme in conda-forge that has appropriate dependencies which play nicely with current versions of Sphinx and Jupyterbook, I think the only "book-specific" packages that we would need are jupyter-book and sphinx-pythia-theme. But that assumes of course that the new sphinx-pythia-theme does not again fall victim to obsolescence, necessitating ever-more complicated pins!

[ahuang11]

Any fixes for this? I'm trying to update https://github.com/ProjectPythia/landsat-ml-cookbook/pull/22 and not sure how to proceed; should I merge with this broken?

Edit: oh I think I just need to follow https://github.com/ProjectPythia/ERA5_interactive-cookbook/pull/9/files

[ktyle]

@ahuang11 let's see how @erogluorhan 's work with ProjectPythia/sphinx-pythia-theme#58 looks with this cookbook.

[brian-rose]

Nightly build is finally passing again with the release of sphinx-pythia-theme v2024.3.0!

[erogluorhan]

I think we can close this now as we've update our Pythia theme, which has fixed this and several other repos' nightly builds. See the discussion for more information about the theme update.

[erogluorhan]

Hey @rmshkv, for using the updated theme in your ongoing cookbook work, please do not forget to check out the How to transition existing cookbooks part of the discussion to see how cookbook-template has been updated to start using the updated theme.