ProjectSidewalk / SidewalkWebpage

Project Sidewalk web page
http://projectsidewalk.org
MIT License
84 stars 24 forks source link

Utilizing Mapillary (in addition to or instead of) GSV #3599

Open jonfroehlich opened 1 month ago

jonfroehlich commented 1 month ago

We've long wanted to be able to support multiple streetscape datasets (e.g., from Mapillary, Apple Maps, Bing Maps).

I spent a bit of time today (while multitasking on Zoom calls) exploring Mapillary.

Mapillary has many advantages—it relies on crowdsourced streetscape data; however, this data is far sparser, more diverse in quality, and not full 360.

Here's the current coverage map of Mapillary: image

Here's the coverage map of Seattle. Looks good on a quick scan but you quickly see many streets without coverage (e.g., in Wallingford, Queen Anne, Ballard, Ravenna, etc.): image

It's worse in less populated areas. Here's Bremerton, for example: image

Here's Poulsbo: image

Here's a comparison with GSV: image

People contribute a variety of data from dashcams, mobile phone images, etc. Here's an example from a dashcam in Seattle but doesn't let you pan the image (so it's a fixed view pointing straight ahead) image

So, my sense is that Mapillary is still not a good enough dataset for us.

On the other hand, it could be a possibility if people are uploading their own 360 images from on-the-ground audits.

jonfroehlich commented 1 month ago

image

Just quickly investigated Apple Look Around.