PygmalionOfCyprus / cmo-db-requests

Public issue/request tracking for the Command: Modern Operations database
49 stars 16 forks source link

China, 750mm BRE10 ballistic missile #1977

Closed LuigiP57 closed 4 weeks ago

LuigiP57 commented 1 year ago

DB Selector

DB3K

Baseline

weapon 779

Hypothetical

No

Name

750mm BRE10 ballistic missile

Length (m)

7.8

Width/Span (m)

0.75

Diameter (m)

0.75

Weight (kg)

4000

Range (nm)

30-325

Target Altitude / Depth (ft)

No response

Target Speed (kts)

No response

Launch Altitude / Depth (ft)

No response

LaunchSpeed (kts)

No response

Warhead

480kg HE

Targets

Land Structure - Soft, Land Structure - Hardened, Runway, Mobile Target - Soft, Mobile Target - Hardened

CEP (m)

10

Sensors

-

Weapon Codes

Ballistic Missile or Rocket Booster, Weapon - INS Navigation, Uses BeiDou/COMPASS, Level Cruise Flight

Comments

Range and CEP are from reasonable speculation.

Sources

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PHL-16 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BRE_(rocket) https://eurasiantimes.com/china-tests-himars-like-rocket-system-that-can-strike-high-altitude-indian/ https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/china/ar-3.htm

LuigiP57 commented 1 year ago

1978

LuigiP57 commented 8 months ago

https://www.sinodefenceforum.com/t/self-propelled-gun-rocket-launcher.7252/page-144 image

claudejdev commented 7 months ago

https://www.sinodefenceforum.com/t/self-propelled-gun-rocket-launcher.7252/page-144 image

Hey there,

just to mention that the actual source is: China Maritime Report No. 32: The PCH191 Modular Long-Range Rocket Launcher: Reshaping the PLA Army's Role in a Cross-Strait Campaign (PDF)

Cheers

LuigiP57 commented 7 months ago

https://www.sinodefenceforum.com/t/self-propelled-gun-rocket-launcher.7252/page-144 image

image

The figures in the chart refer to the data of the export version of the weapon series. Selfuse versions are supposed to have a longer range

PygmalionOfCyprus commented 4 weeks ago

Duplicate of #1978

LuigiP57 commented 4 weeks ago

@PygmalionOfCyprus Wait, you closed the self used version of the 750mm tactical missile, then what range of this missile will PLAGF get? Will it still be 500km?

PygmalionOfCyprus commented 4 weeks ago

Oh, I see, this is meant for the domestic use version.

Usually with domestic/export distinctions unless we have a specific number for the domestic version we just give them the export specs until we learn otherwise. A lot of weapon systems probably perform better domestically than their officially published export specs, but it would lead to a real mess of creating different versions that may or may not actually exist.

If we can get a CCTV piece or something saying that their 750mm missile goes "more than X km" or something we can take that and run with it. Though considering we haven't even seen the 750mm rocket in service with the PLA yet (only implied) that might be a bit.

yU2187sie commented 4 weeks ago

image image In fact, in photos released by Chinese state media, PLAGF's PCH-191 is already equipped with 750mm tactical missiles. https://x.com/BC_Xuanming/status/1722938962778702218 @PygmalionOfCyprus

yU2187sie commented 4 weeks ago

In fact, we can apply data similar to the FD480 9K720 missile and DF-12 can find that the FD480 and the latter two weapons compared to the same specifications, so the FD480 for domestic use version is able to reach a range of 480KM. We refer to the data of the Turkish tayfun missile, whose technology originated from the Chinese WS-1, and can find that the range of the same type of Turkish missile can even reach 560KM under similar specifications. We all know that there is a clear gap between the weapons in foreign trade and the self-use type, so I cannot understand choosing only a range of 280KM on this weapon without acknowledging that it has a range of 480KM. https://missilethreat.csis.org/missile/df-12/ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/9K720_Iskander https://www.aa.com.tr/en/turkiye/turkish-defense-giant-successfully-tests-ballistic-missile-tayfun/2903920

LuigiP57 commented 4 weeks ago

Oh, I see, this is meant for the domestic use version.

Usually with domestic/export distinctions unless we have a specific number for the domestic version we just give them the export specs until we learn otherwise. A lot of weapon systems probably perform better domestically than their officially published export specs, but it would lead to a real mess of creating different versions that may or may not actually exist.

If we can get a CCTV piece or something saying that their 750mm missile goes "more than X km" or something we can take that and run with it. Though considering we haven't even seen the 750mm rocket in service with the PLA yet (only implied) that might be a bit.

It is essentially impossible to get information from Chinese state-affiliated media about the range of certain weapons. This is why OSINT and website like SDF are particularly important. "Collect - Sift - Obtain valuable information - Form sound inferences"

In the case of the PLAGF self-used 750mm TBM, there was already enough discussion last November. I thought you'd already seen this stuff, as someone who also gets information from the SDF.

https://www.sinodefenceforum.com/t/self-propelled-gun-rocket-launcher.7252/page-142

For the self-used version of the FD480, the mainstream view is no less than 500km firing range. Considering that the Tayfun missile quoted above is capable of reaching a range of 560km derived from early Chinese long-range rocket technology, I would like to perhaps increase the maximum range to 600km.

What do you think? @PygmalionOfCyprus

PygmalionOfCyprus commented 3 weeks ago

Wow, thanks guys. I totally dropped the ball on this one. I hadn't seen the SDF thread and didn't realize the Chinese had A. released photos of the 750mm in service and B. that we had reasonable estimates on range based on the Tayfun lineage.

Considering that the Tayfun missile quoted above is capable of reaching a range of 560km derived from early Chinese long-range rocket technology, I would like to perhaps increase the maximum range to 600km.

This makes sense to me. I'll make the necessary additions.